This proposal has become dormant through lack of discussion by the community. It is inactive but retained for historical interest. If you want to revive discussion on this subject, try using the talk page or start a discussion at the village pump.

Notability
Specific guidelines
Academics Books Criminal acts Events Films Music Numbers Organizations & companies People Web content
Active proposals
Academic journals Bilateral relationships Law Media, TV, and radio Streets, roads, and highways
See also
Common deletion outcomes Why was my page deleted?

Contents 1 OPTION ONE 2 OPTION TWO 3 OPTION THREE 4 See also

[edit] OPTION ONE

This guideline is a specific exception to WP:Notability.

Based on recent consensus demonstrated at numerous AfD discussions, every geographic location or entity that has a name and a verified location is suitable for inclusion as a topic of an article in Wikipedia.

[edit] OPTION TWO

Geographic locations are not inherently notable. Geographic locations are not offered any special consideration for notability, and, since atlases and censuses are comprehensive listings that do not constitute a direct and detailed examination of a location, they are specifically deprecated as a source of notability for a geographic location.

[edit] OPTION THREE

Because Wikipedia prides itself on its inclusiveness and expansiveness over traditional paper encyclopedias, it can have an article on any populated place, no matter how small. However, since users turn to Wikipedia for its higher quality of information than they can find on other internet sites, all articles on populated places must meet a high standard of WP:Verifiability.

Specifically, an article must have;

1. a name that is either confirmed by the government of the place or by a reliable secondary source,
2. a cited population estimate or range, such as a census report, and
3. coordinates that can be confirmed to point unambiguously to the place.

In practice, this means that an article cannot be sourced only by GEOnet Names Server or the commercial websites that themselves only use unimproved GNS data.

[edit] See also

• Wikipedia:Notability (geography), an essay
• Wikipedia:Geographic imbalance
• WP:LOCAL