| # | Episode Title | Air Date | Challenge | Winner | Back To Reality (Losers In Bold) |
| 1 | Welcome To Celebrity Island | January 8, 2007 | "Celebrity Autograph" — Random Audience members were asked of which star they would most like to meet and get their picture taken with. The three celebrities with the lowest number of fans lost | Rob Van Winkle | Andrea Lowell, Chyna Doll and Verne Troyer (Sent to The B-List) |
| 2 | Sex, Size, and Videotape | January 15, 2007 | "Scandal Video" — Teams of two had to make a scandalous video that lasted no more than 30 seconds. The team that won chose the next three celebrities to play back to reality. | Rob Van Winkle and Andrea Lowell | Emmanuel Lewis, Traci Bingham and Brigitte Nielsen (Sent to The B-List) |
| 3 | Down and Out on the B-List | January 22, 2007 | "Green Screen Challenge" — Each team was given a script to memorize and then perform in front of a green screen. The three celebrities that did the worst acting jobs lost | Rob Van Winkle | CC Deville, Ron Jeremy and Emmanuel Lewis (Sent to The B-List) |
| 4 | The Chyna Doll Syndrome | January 29, 2007 | "Hotel Trash Challenge" — Both teams had identical "hotel rooms" to trash. Whichever team trashed their hotel room more won the challenge. The losing team sent three players back to reality. | A-List | Chyna Doll, Brigitte Nielsen and Verne Troyer (Originally eliminated from the show, but Brigitte Nielsen offered to eliminate herself.) |
| 5 | V for Variety | February 11, 2007 | "Variety Show Challenge" — Both teams had to put on a variety show for a live audience. The team that got the loudest applause won the challenge. The losing team sent three players back to reality. | B-List | Ron Jeremy, Pepa Denton and CC Deville (Eliminated) |
| 6 | Pretty Women | February 18, 2007 | "Hooker Challenge" — Each team had to choose out of a large group of hookers and club dancers only fifteen girls. whichever team had the least amount of hookers in their fifteen choices won. The losing team sent three players back to reality. | A-List | Verne Troyer, Chyna Doll and Emmanuel Lewis (Eliminated) |
| 7 | Dial M for Mommy | March 4, 2007 | "Surreal Life Telethon" — Each celebrity had to call as many famous people as they knew. Out of the people called, 50 were selected as the top 50. Players then received points based on if someone they called made the top 50 list. For instance, if Jim Carrey was ranked 40 they player who called him received 10 points. The person who received the least amount of points was instantly eliminated. | Rob van Winkle | Chyna Doll (Eliminated, possibly because Andrea Lowell manipulated Kennedy, who judged the fame of each celebrity who was called) |
| 8 | Peeping Toms | March 11, 2007 | "Paparazzi Challenge" — The teams were sent to a resort for a day of relaxation, however, they didn't know that it was a secret challenge, in which paparazzi snapped scandalous shots of the Fame Gamers. The three celebrities with the worst photos would go to Back to Reality. | Verne Troyer | Ron Jeremy,Rob van Winkle, Andrea Lowell |
| 9 | Five Weasly Pieces | March 18, 2007 | "Surreal Life Fan Challenge" — The remaining contestants were attached to one of their fans. However, they had to stay attached no matter what, and separating would let an alarm go off, thus eliminating them from the game. | Ron Jeremy and Rob Van Winkle | Pepa, Traci Bingham and Verne Troyer |
| 10 | The Ice Ice Storm [Season Finale] | March 25, 2007 | "Commercial Making Challenge" | Traci Bingham | Back to Reality 1 (Contestants vote for the person they want to go home...majority vote goes home) Contestants: Ron Jeremy, Pepa, Rob Van Winkle Back to Reality 2 Contestants: Ron Jeremy and Pepa Final Two: Traci Bingham and Ron Jeremy |
