| advertise add site services publishers database health videos | ![]() | about toolbar stats live show health store more stuff JOIN/LOGIN |
Talking Watch, Talking Watches, Talking Clock, Talking Bible, Talking... independentliving.com | Braces and More | Orthodontist in Sunnyvale, CA (California) | People... shimizu-orthodontics.com | Talk Radio Show Tooth Talk Dr. Mitchell A. Josephs D.D.S.Products radiotoothtalk.com |
[edit] Message to MitsubeHi, Regarding this sentence: "Adi Shankara is believed to be the founder of the Dashanami monastic order and the Shanmata tradition of worship". I am changing it to" "Adi Shankara is believed to be the organizer of the Dashanami monastic order and the founder of the Shanmata tradition of worship". Please see the page Dashanami_Sampradaya. The dasanami / ekadandi tradition and their monastries have existed before the birth of Sri Adi Shankara. Adi Shankara founded a form of worship by merging various hindu beleifs / factions into the Shanmata tradition and founded four mutts to help organize the methodology of worship as well as provide an organized support base for hinduism. He did not found the dasanami / ekadandi tradition. The dasanamis / ekadandis have existed even in the Pallava and Pandya periods. Thanks. --Illusion 06:26, 4 May 2009 (UTC)Mayasutra —Preceding unsigned comment added by Mayasutra (talk • contribs)
[edit] Poorly Sourced & Consequentially Wildly Inaccuratehi, this article is severely poor. im not sure if anyone has realised but the main text to which the information about sankara is credited Sankara-Dig-Vijaya is actually a mythological text written around 1600 AD called a hagiography that bears little or no relevance to the historicity of the life of sankara. as an example, it is seriously academically doubted that sankara founded the mathas - though this is accepted as hindu tradition it should be noted so and not as historical fact as this is far from the truth. indeed, even the dating here is innacurate. i'm a 2nd year indian civilisation student at the university of edinburgh, and am in the middle an essay on sankara so dont have time to edit the article myself, but i can point anyone interested in the direction of a number of academic works. a hagiography is a mythological/folk tale written around 1000 years after sankaras death to eulogise him in the face of contention from other religions. it is contextually reactive and other than indicating to one the reverence of sankara it has no historical value ! luke. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 87.112.72.23 (talk) 15:17, 10 February 2008 (UTC) [edit] Archive[edit] Sanskrit and MalayalamI noticed that the pronunciation of some Malayalam words are given in IAST system. I was wondering if IAST could transliterate Malayalam correctly too? Are all the sounds in Malayalam portray-able in IAST? -- thunderboltza.k.a.Deepu Joseph |TALK13:37, 27 July 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Visarga is missingPlease add visarga after the word आदि शंकर in Devanagari. Apnavana 02:45, 11 August 2006 (UTC) [edit] आदि शंकरMy computer has indic enabled, yet I see the hindi/ devnagari spelling wrong in the article page. Can anyone explain why? Its comes ok here. Is unicode causing it to come out wrongly there? -- Lost(talk) 06:26, 23 August 2006 (UTC)
[edit] featured article editingThis article is posted as a featured article. What is not said is that the article as featured is edited. I don't know how the editing is done, but leaving out the birth/death years makes the article very weak. Kdammers 06:13, 7 October 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Interesting...Hi, I just finished a cource in Comparative Religion at Uppsala University in Hinduism and Buddism and now I find that Adi Shankara is Today's featured article :-) Good idea,.. how is the prosess of choosing Today's featured article made? In my MS Explorer (Swedish version) there is a bit strange signs: Malayalam: ആദി ശങ്കരന്, Check out Eco Theology article if you whant some info about Ecology and Theology and please help to develop that article so that soon itcould be Today's featured article? --Swedenborg 12:11, 7 October 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Dear Hinduism Project membersDear Hinduism Project members and others interested in Hindusim There is a controversy on the Hinduism regarding Raja Yoga. Please read the debate on the Hinduism discussion page. Your comments are requested on the Hinduism discussion page to help resolve the controversy. Thank you. HeBhagawan 14:46, 8 October 2006 (UTC) [edit] DatesIf the modern scholarship is agreed on the 788 – 820 CE date, then shouldn't that be the date specified in the introduction? -Cibu 04:30, 14 October 2006 (UTC) [edit] Upanishad BhasyasDidn't Adi Shankara comment on Eleven upanishads? Syiem 13:14, 20 November 2006 (UTC) [edit] Defeating The JainasThe following is an extract from the Dig-Vijaya sub-section of this article: "He then defeated the Jainas at a place called Bahlika". The word "defeated" does not clearly indicate the nature of defeat of the Jainas. Were they defeated militarily or in a debate? TathD 14:46, 10 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Sources citedThe article cites three books: by Swami Tapasyananda, by Keay and by Greaves. Most of the references are to the book by Tapasyananda and there is only one to Greave's book and none to Keay's. COuld somebody please explain why it is like that or add some more inline citations? Kkrystian 10:38, 21 June 2007 (UTC) [edit] Adi Shankara's GotraDoes anyone have the idea of Adi Shankara's Gotra?BalanceRestored 06:21, 6 July 2007 (UTC) There are local mythologies that his father was a Twoshta. Vedic decent of TWOSHTRI.There is a sloka in sankaradvigvijayam revealing his gothra as Abhuvana twoshta viswakarma. Acharyo sankaro nama Twoshta putra nisamshaya Viprakula gurorvdweeksha Viswakarman to brahmana Sloka published in Kesari Annual magzine in 1978 by Dr. Sadasiva sharma ,Palakkad, Kerala. Write up The gothras of Viswakarma Rsi. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 122.164.229.5 (talk) 07:46, 29 March 2008 (UTC) [edit] Proposal to rename this articleThe birth name of the subject of this article was Shankara and he was later given the title acharya. To distinguish him from his successors, each of whom assumed the name-title Shankaracharya, he was called Adi Shankaracharya. To call him Adi Shankara is incorrect (the first Shankara is Shiva). Therefore I propose that this article be renamed to Shankara. There is no reason for the Shankara disambiguation page to exist, as the name is usually associated with the subject of this article and it only rarely refers to Shiva besides. Tseno Maximov (talk) 16:55, 27 November 2007 (UTC) [edit] Debate with Ubhaya BharatiI find odd the statement that after forcing Shankara to acquire knowledge of kamashastra Ubhaya Bharati declined to debate with him. The biographies of Shnakara which I've read, both online and in print, state that the debate with Unhaya Bharati was completed. Tseno Maximov (talk) 16:55, 27 November 2007 (UTC) [edit] Contribution to Mathematics"Adi Shankaracharya was not only a saint of profound spiritual insight, but also helped develop scientific concepts. It is believed that Adi Shankara was the first mathematician to use the concept of Number Line (Ref: "Sankara Bhaashyam" (4-4-25) of the "Brihadaaranyaka Upanishad"), the idea of assigning a set of natural numbers to a straight line. As the number of elements in a set of natural numbers is infinite, it requires a symbol of infinity to represent them. A straight line can be considered to be infinitely long. Adi Shankara adopted a straight line as a symbol of infinity. A straight line can be divided to infinite number of parts and each of these parts can be assigned the value of a particular number. This is called number line. Though his concept lacks the perfection of modern number line theory, Sree Sankaran exhibited his intellectual ingenuity in conceiving such a novel idea.[1] Yet another example for Sree Sankaran's unbiased and pure scientific pursuit of knowledge could be seen in the second "Slokam" (verse) of Soundarya Lahari (a collection of 100 Slokams in praise of Goddess Durga written by Adi Shankara). In the Slokam Thaneeyaamsam paamsum thava charana pankeruhabhavam, we can see a hint to the theory of inter-convertibility of mass and energy (the famous equation E = MC² put forward by Albert Einstein).[2] In another context, Adi Shankara postulated that the diameter of Sun is 1 lakh "Yojanas". Later the modern scientific community calculated the diameter which agreed very closely with (just 3% error) the value provided by Adi Shankara.[3]" Removed since the website is not WP:RS. The Namboothiri-trust website may tend to glorify members of it's community. The website does not list it's sources for it's assertions about Shankara's knoweledge of Maths and might be WP:OR.--Redtigerxyz (talk) 06:02, 21 June 2008 (UTC) [edit] Shankara born as Brahmin?Is this really true? I know a movie, where he was given Brahmin status by another Brahmin. Please check this one. --Thirusivaperur (talk) 16:02, 25 July 2008 (UTC) He is almost certainly a Nambudiri. But yea, a source would be helpful. Trips (talk) 06:00, 26 July 2008 (UTC) Local mythologies prevailing around Aluva in KERALA is that Sankara's father was a Viswakarma who married a Namboothiri lady,and thus got thrown out of the community.This frustht may be a reason of these communities non participation of the funeral of sankara's mother. Local viswakarmans are still celibrating sankara jayanthy by there own. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 122.164.241.127 (talk) 05:56, 21 September 2008 (UTC) [edit] God?In the "Historical and cultural effect" section, it is stated that Shankara exhorted his followers to worship God. According to Schopenhauer's On the Will in Nature, in the "Sinology" chapter, Westerners are always trying to find their God in other religions. Steeped from childhood in the concept of a Judeo–Christian anthropomorphic God, Westerners can't understand how a religion can exist without such a being. Are we sure that Shankara's Vedanta refers to a humanoid God who created, supervises, and controls the universe? Is this presentation of God in Vedanta merely a Western European assumption?Lestrade (talk) 17:05, 31 October 2008 (UTC)Lestrade [edit] ReinsertAdi Shankara begins his Gurustotram or Verses to the Guru with the following Sanskrit Sloka, that has become a widely sung Bhajan:
I wonder why this has been deleted by somebody. Is this information not true? or is there anybody who dislikes that kind of information?
slightly different translation is to be found [1] here I don't know the name of the above quoted Shloka, how to find a source apt for wikipedia?
Okay, the title/name is Guru Stotram.
The song is to be found here [6], no direct link available.
[edit] No need of Devanagari
Adi Shankara is from Kerala by birth. --91.130.91.84 (talk) 12:51, 10 January 2009 (UTC)
The wikipedia page for biographies states, that the article should be conservatively written. In any case of biographies in whole wikipedia, this means, that the ethnicity of the person is used only, since any other script mislead the reader. The reader could think, that this person is of Marathi or any other ethnicity using the Devanagari script which is certainly wrong and misleading. To keep it conservative, the Devanagari script has to be removed. --Leadcorrector (talk) 15:10, 10 January 2009 (UTC)
This is a stupid debate. Neither Malayalam the language, nor its script, nor the Devanagari script are attested at Shankara's time. His ethnicity is now assumed to Malayali because of his place of birth, but given that the area could be considered to be part of the wider 'Tamil country' of those times, perhaps his name should be written in Tamil instead (that's not a serious suggestion). I vote for keeping Devanagari for clarity. Imc (talk) 16:52, 10 January 2009 (UTC)
[edit] VoteFor clearer view of the consensus, please include your sign (* --~~~~) in the relevant section. Please continue the comments above. [edit] Include Devanagari
[edit] Exclude Devanagari[edit] Bypassers commentOld debate to which I can only shake my head. The correct argument is of course that the article should be informative for the users of the encyclopedia, not conservative. If many readers are served by his name being written in Devanagari, then the name should be written in Devanagari. Same reasoning for Tamil and for Malayalam, irrespective of whether it was spoken at that time. ... said: Rursus (mbork³) 19:52, 5 August 2009 (UTC)
[edit] Reference to Shankara in Hindu Meditation section of MeditationI have been trying to place a sentence in the Hindu meditation section of the 'meditation' article that Adi Shankara is generally regarded as a primary exponent and theoretician about Hindu meditation. These have been deleted by editor Mitsube with the comment that Shankara didn't write or practise meditation to any eminent degree within the Hindu tradition. Anyone who has read Shankara's books (not merely googled for references about him on- line, including biographies about him) must challenge this. I suspect it is part of an ideological agenda to claim that Hindu meditation began with the Buddha.Fauncet (talk) 14:10, 24 June 2009 (UTC)
Categories: Wikipedia featured articles | Featured articles that have appeared on the main page | Old requests for peer review | FA-Class India articles | FA-Class India articles of Low-importance | Low-importance India articles | FA-Class Kerala articles | Mid-importance Kerala articles | WikiProject Kerala articles | FA-Class Kerala articles of Mid-importance | FA-Class Indian history articles | Unknown-importance Indian history articles | WikiProject Indian history articles | FA-Class Indian history articles of Unknown-importance | Indian portal selected articles | WikiProject India articles | FA-Class biography articles | WikiProject Biography articles | FA-Class Hinduism articles | High-importance Hinduism articles | FA-Class Hindu philosophy articles | High-importance Hindu philosophy articles | FA-Class Philosophy articles | High-importance Philosophy articles | FA-Class philosophy of religion articles | High-importance philosophy of religion articles | Philosophy of religion task force articles | FA-Class philosopher articles | High-importance philosopher articles | Philosophers task force articles | FA-Class Eastern philosophy articles | High-importance Eastern philosophy articles | Eastern philosophy task force articles | FA-Class Medieval philosophy articles | High-importance Medieval philosophy articles | Medieval philosophy task force articles | Wikipedia Version 0.5 | Wikipedia CD Selection-0.5 | Wikipedia Release Version | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ↑ top of page ↑ | about thumbshots |