| No. | Name | Party | Assumed office | Left office | Period |
| 1 | Boyle Finniss | | 24 October 1856 | 21 August 1857 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000301.000000301 days |  |
| 2 | John Baker | | 21 August 1857 | 1 September 1857 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000011.00000011 days |  |
| 3 | Robert Torrens | | 1 September 1857 | 30 September 1857 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000029.00000029 days |  |
| 4 | Richard Hanson | | 30 September 1857 | 9 May 1860 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000222.000000222 days |  |
| 5 | Thomas Reynolds | | 9 May 1860 | 8 October 1861 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000152.000000152 days |  |
| 6 | George Waterhouse | | 8 October 1861 | 4 July 1863 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000269.000000269 days |  |
| 7 | Francis Dutton | | 4 July 1863 | 15 July 1863 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000011.00000011 days |  |
| 8 | Henry Ayers | | 15 July 1863 | 4 August 1864 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000020.00000020 days |  |
| 9 | Arthur Blyth | | 4 August 1864 | 22 March 1865 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000230.000000230 days |  |
| - | Francis Dutton (2nd time) | | 22 March 1865 | 20 September 1865 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000182.000000182 days Total - 193 days | |
| - | Henry Ayers (2nd time) | | 20 September 1865 | 23 October 1865 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000033.00000033 days Total - 1 year, 53 days | |
| 10 | John Hart | | 23 October 1865 | 28 March 1866 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000156.000000156 days |  |
| 11 | James Boucaut | | 28 March 1866 | 3 May 1867 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000036.00000036 days |  |
| - | Henry Ayers (3rd time) | | 3 May 1867 | 24 September 1868 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000144.000000144 days Total - 2 years, 197 days | |
| - | John Hart (2nd time) | | 24 September 1868 | 13 October 1868 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000019.00000019 days Total - 175 days | |
| - | Henry Ayers (4th time) | | 13 October 1868 | 3 November 1868 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000021.00000021 days Total - 2 years, 218 days | |
| 12 | Henry Strangways | | 3 November 1868 | 30 May 1870 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000208.000000208 days |  |
| - | John Hart (3rd time) | | 30 May 1870 | 10 November 1871 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000164.000000164 days Total - 1 year, 339 days | |
| - | Arthur Blyth (2nd time) | | 10 November 1871 | 22 January 1872 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000073.00000073 days Total - 303 days | |
| - | Henry Ayers (5th time) | | 22 January 1872 | 22 July 1873 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000181.000000181 days Total - 4 years, 34 days | |
| - | Arthur Blyth (3rd time) | | 22 July 1873 | 3 June 1875 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000316.000000316 days Total - 2 years, 254 days | |
| - | James Boucaut (2nd time) | | 3 June 1875 | 6 June 1876 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000003.0000003 days Total - 2 years, 39 days | |
| 13 | John Colton | | 6 June 1876 | 26 October 1877 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000142.000000142 days |  |
| - | James Boucaut (3rd time) | | 26 October 1877 | 27 September 1878 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000336.000000336 days Total - 3 years, 10 days | |
| 14 | William Morgan | | 27 September 1878 | 24 June 1881 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000270.000000270 days |  |
| 15 | John Cox Bray | | 24 June 1881 | 16 June 1884 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000358.000000358 days |  |
| - | John Colton (2nd time) | | 16 June 1884 | 16 June 1885 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 days Total - 2 years, 142 days | |
| 16 | John Downer | | 16 June 1885 | 11 June 1887 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000360.000000360 days |  |
| 17 | Thomas Playford II | | 11 June 1887 | 27 June 1889 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000016.00000016 days |  |
| 18 | John Cockburn | | 27 June 1889 | 19 August 1890 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000053.00000053 days |  |
| - | Thomas Playford II (2nd time) | | 19 August 1890 | 21 June 1892 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000307.000000307 days Total - 3 years, 323 days | |
| 19 | Frederick Holder | | 21 June 1892 | 15 October 1892 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000116.000000116 days |  |
| - | John Downer (2nd time) | conservatism[1] | 15 October 1892 | 16 June 1893 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000244.000000244 days Total - 2 year, 239 days | |
| 20 | Charles Kingston | liberalism | 16 June 1893 | 1 December 1899 | &0000000000000006.0000006 years, &0000000000000168.000000168 days |  |
| 21 | Vaiben Solomon | conservatism | 1 December 1899 | 8 December 1899 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000007.0000007 days |  |
| - | Frederick Holder (2nd time) | liberalism | 8 December 1899 | 15 May 1901 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000158.000000158 days Total - 1 year, 274 days | |
| 22 | John Jenkins | liberalism | 15 May 1901 | 1 March 1905 | &0000000000000003.0000003 years, &0000000000000290.000000290 days |  |
| 23 | Richard Butler | conservatism | 1 March 1905 | 26 July 1905 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000147.000000147 days |  |
| 24 | Thomas Price | Australian Labor Party (Labor) | 26 July 1905 | 5 June 1909 | &0000000000000003.0000003 years, &0000000000000314.000000314 days |  |
| 25 | Archibald Peake | Liberal and Democratic Union | 5 June 1909 | 3 June 1910 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000363.000000363 days |  |
| 26 | John Verran | Labor | 3 June 1910 | 17 February 1912 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000259.000000259 days |  |
| - | Archibald Peake (2nd time) | Liberal Union | 17 February 1912 | 3 April 1915 | &0000000000000003.0000003 years, &0000000000000045.00000045 days Total - 4 years, 43 days | |
| 27 | Crawford Vaughan | Labor | 3 April 1915 | 14 July 1917 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000102.000000102 days |  |
| - | Archibald Peake (3rd time) | Liberal Union | 14 July 1917 | 8 April 1920 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000269.000000269 days Total - 6 years, 312 days | |
| 28 | Henry Barwell | Liberal Union/ Liberal Federation | 8 April 1920 | 16 April 1924 | &0000000000000004.0000004 years, &0000000000000008.0000008 days |  |
| 29 | John Gunn | Labor | 16 April 1924 | 28 August 1926 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000134.000000134 days |  |
| 30 | Lionel Hill | Labor | 28 August 1926 | 8 April 1927 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000223.000000223 days |  |
| 31 | Richard L. Butler | Liberal Federation | 8 April 1927 | 17 April 1930 | &0000000000000003.0000003 years, &0000000000000009.0000009 days |  |
| - | Lionel Hill (2nd time) | Labor | 17 April 1930 | 13 February 1933 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000302.000000302 days Total - 3 years, 160 days | |
| 32 | Robert Richards | Labor | 13 February 1933 | 18 April 1933 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000064.00000064 days |  |
| - | Richard L. Butler (2nd time) | Liberal and Country League (LCL) | 18 April 1933 | 5 November 1938 | &0000000000000005.0000005 years, &0000000000000201.000000201 days Total - 8 years, 210 days | |
| 33 | Thomas Playford IV | LCL | 5 November 1938 | 10 March 1965 | &0000000000000026.00000026 years, &0000000000000125.000000125 days |  |
| 34 | Frank Walsh | Labor | 10 March 1965 | 1 June 1967 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000083.00000083 days | |
| 35 | Don Dunstan | Labor | 1 June 1967 | 17 April 1968 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000321.000000321 days |  |
| 36 | Steele Hall | LCL | 17 April 1968 | 2 June 1970 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000046.00000046 days | |
| - | Don Dunstan (2nd time) | Labor | 2 June 1970 | 15 February 1979 | &0000000000000008.0000008 years, &0000000000000258.000000258 days Total - 9 years, 214 days | |
| 37 | Des Corcoran | Labor | 15 February 1979 | 18 September 1979 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000215.000000215 days | |
| 38 | David Tonkin | Liberal Party of Australia (Liberal) | 18 September 1979 | 10 November 1982 | &0000000000000003.0000003 years, &0000000000000053.00000053 days | |
| 39 | John Bannon | Labor | 10 November 1982 | 4 September 1992 | &0000000000000009.0000009 years, &0000000000000299.000000299 days |  |
| 40 | Lynn Arnold | Labor | 4 September 1992 | 14 December 1993 | &0000000000000001.0000001 year, &0000000000000101.000000101 days | |
| 41 | Dean Brown | Liberal | 14 December 1993 | 28 November 1996 | &0000000000000002.0000002 years, &0000000000000350.000000350 days | |
| 42 | John Olsen | Liberal | 28 November 1996 | 22 October 2001 | &0000000000000004.0000004 years, &0000000000000328.000000328 days | |
| 43 | Rob Kerin | Liberal | 22 October 2001 | 5 April 2002 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 years, &0000000000000165.000000165 days | |
| 44 | Mike Rann | Labor | 5 April 2002 | Incumbent | &0000000000000007.0000007 years, &0000000000000277.000000277 days[2] |  |
In the following timeline, the legend includes the Liberal and Democratic Union and later the Liberal Union with the Liberal Federation. The grey area represents duration of Playmander electoral malapportionment.