| Years | Date | Competition | Type | First trophy awarded, years | Original code | Current code | Location | Notes |
| 1858– | 7 August | Melbourne Grammar School-Scotch College | schools fixture | Cordner-Eggleston Cup, 1989– | experimental | Australian rules football | Melbourne, Australia | [1][2] |
| 1861–1876 | December | Caledonian Challenge Cup | club trophy | Caledonian Challenge Cup, 1861–1864 | Melbourne Rules | defunct | Melbourne, Australia | [3] Later trophy donated by the Athletic Sports Committee before becoming the South Yarra Challenge Cup. |
| 1867 only | | Youdan Cup | club trophy | Youdan Cup, 1867 | Sheffield Rules | defunct | Sheffield, England | |
| 1868 only | | Cromwell Cup | club trophy | Cromwell Cup, 1868 | Sheffield Rules | defunct | Sheffield, England | |
| 1871– | | FA Cup | club trophy | FA Cup, 1871– | Association Football | Association Football | England | oldest surviving football competition/trophy in the world |
| 1874– | | United Hospitals Challenge Cup | club trophy | Challenge Cup | rugby football | Rugby Union | Surrey, England | oldest rugby football competition in the world |
| 1874– | | Scottish Cup | national club trophy | Scottish Cup 1874– | Association Football | Association Football | Scotland | oldest national trophy in the world |
| ~1875–[4] | | Bromsgrove–KESB | schools fixture | Siviter-Smith Cup, 1935– | rugby football | Rugby Union | Bromsgrove/Birmingham, England | Later trophy donated by Paul Siviter-Smith, a Birmingham businessman, who had sons at both schools.[5] |
| 1877– | 30 April | South Australian Football Association | club league | Thomas Seymour Hill Premiership Trophy, ? | Australian rules football | Australian rules football | Adelaide, South Australia | oldest Australian rules football league and earliest governing body |
| 1877– | 17 May | Victorian Football Association | club league | ? | Victorian Rules | Australian rules football | Melbourne, Australia | most influential early governing body for Australian rules football |
| 1879– | | Tasmanian Football League | club league | ? | Victorian Rules | Australian rules football | Hobart, Tasmania, Australia | some discontinuity, most recently dormant between 2001-2008 and returns in 2009 |
| 1879– | 10 March | Calcutta Cup | international challenge | ? | Rugby football | Rugby union | England, Scotland | competed for by the England and Scotland international rugby teams annually |
| 1880– | | Bendigo Football League | club league | ? | Victorian Rules | Australian rules football | Bendigo, Australia | includes the Castlemaine football club, second oldest football club in Australia |
| 1882–? | | Northern Football Association | club league | ? | Victorian Rules | defunct | Launceston, Tasmania | clubs included Launceston, City and Longford |
| 1883– | | Black Diamond Football League | club league | Black Diamond Challenge Cup, 1887– | Australian Rules Football | Australian rules football | Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia | [6] trophy donated to the league by Newcastle’s Richmond Tobacco Co. claims to be the longest running football trophy in Australia |
| 1885– | | West Australian Football League | club league | ? | Australian rules football | Australian rules football | Perth, Western Australia | |
| 1888– | | The Football League | club league | ? | Association Football | Association Football | | oldest association football league |
| 1888– | | Durand Cup | Tournament | Royal Scots Fusiliers, 1988- | Experimental | All India Football Federation | Shimla, India | Oldest football Tournament in India |
| 1888– | | Broken Hill Football League | club league | ? | Australian rules football | Australian rules football | Broken Hill, New South Wales, Australia | |
| 1896– | | Australian Football League | club league | Flag 1895-; AFL Premiership Cup, 1959– | Australian Rules Football | Australian rules football | Victoria, Australia (national since 1990) | premiership flag awarded since 1895. Now the game's premier competition and highest governing body. |
| 1898– | | Yates Cup | college league | | Canadian football | Canadian football | Ontario, Canada | The Ontario University Athletics football trophy and oldest football trophy in North America, won by the Western Ontario Mustangs a record 28 times. |
| 1901– | | New South Wales Suburban Rugby Union | club league | | Rugby union | Rugby union | Sydney, Australia | |
| 1903– | | Sydney AFL | club league | | Australian Rules Football | Australian rules football | Sydney, Australia | |
| 1904– | | AFL Queensland State League | club league | | Australian Rules Football | Australian rules football | Brisbane, Australia | |
| 1908– | | New South Wales Rugby League | club league | | Rugby League | rugby league | Sydney, Australia |
| 1908– | | Hong Kong First Division League | club league | | Football League | football league | Hong Kong, China |
| 1909– | | Grey Cup | Originally national club trophy; now national league | | "Rugby football" (early form of Canadian football) | Canadian football | Canada | Now the championship trophy of the Canadian Football League. |
| 1910– | | Newcastle Rugby League | club league | | Rugby League | rugby league | Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia | |
| 1911– | | Illawarra Rugby League | club league | | Rugby League | rugby league | Illawarra, New South Wales, Australia | |