In addition to the Newbery medal the committee awards additional citations referred to as the Newbery Honor to worthy runners-up. Though the Newbery Honor was initiated in 1971, specially cited runners-up for the Newbery Medal from previous years were retroactively named Newbery Honor books.
| Year | Author | Book | Citation |
| 1922 | Loon,Hendrik Willem van Hendrik Willem van Loon | Story of Mankind,The The Story of Mankind | Winner |
| 1922 | Hawes,Charles Charles Hawes | Great Quest,The The Great Quest | Honor |
| 1922 | Marshall,Bernard Bernard Marshall | Cedric the Forester | Honor |
| 1922 | Bowen,William William Bowen | Old Tobacco Shop: A True Account of What Befell a Little Boy in Search of Adventure,The The Old Tobacco Shop: A True Account of What Befell a Little Boy in Search of Adventure | Honor |
| 1922 | Colum,Padraic Padraic Colum | Golden Fleece and The Heroes Who Lived Before Achilles,The The Golden Fleece and The Heroes Who Lived Before Achilles | Honor |
| 1922 | Meigs,Cornelia Cornelia Meigs | Windy Hill,The The Windy Hill | Honor |
| 1923 | Lofting,Hugh Hugh Lofting | Voyages of Doctor Dolittle,The The Voyages of Doctor Dolittle | Winner |
| 1924 | Hawes,Charles Charles Hawes | Dark Frigate,The The Dark Frigate | Winner |
| 1925 | Finger,Charles Charles Finger | Tales from Silver Lands | Winner |
| 1925 | Moore,Annie Carroll Annie Carroll Moore | Nicholas: A Manhattan Christmas Story | Honor |
| 1925 | Parrish,Anne Anne Parrish | Dream Coach,The The Dream Coach | Honor |
| 1926 | Chrisman,Arthur Bowie Arthur Bowie Chrisman | Shen of the Sea | Winner |
| 1926 | Colum,Padraic Padraic Colum | Voyagers: Being Legends and Romances of Atlantic Discovery,The The Voyagers: Being Legends and Romances of Atlantic Discovery | Honor |
| 1927 | James,Will Will James | Smoky the Cow Horse | Winner |
| 1928 | Mukerji,Dhan Gopal Dhan Gopal Mukerji | Gay Neck, the Story of a Pigeon | Winner |
| 1928 | Young,Ella Ella Young | Wonder Smith and His Son,The The Wonder Smith and His Son | Honor |
| 1928 | Sneeker,Caroline Caroline Snedeker | Downright Dencey | Honor |
| 1929 | Kelly,Eric P. Eric P. Kelly | Trumperter of Krakow The Trumpeter of Krakow | Winner |
| 1929 | Bennett,John John Bennett | Pigtail of Ah Lee Ben Loo | Honor |
| 1929 | Gag,Wanda Wanda Gág | Millions of Cats | Honor |
| 1929 | Hallock,Grace Grace Hallock | Boy Who Was,The The Boy Who Was | Honor |
| 1929 | Meigs,Cornelia Cornelia Meigs | Clearing Weather | Honor |
| 1929 | Moon,Grace Grace Moon | Runaway Papoose | Honor |
| 1929 | Whitney,Elinor Elinor Whitney | Tod of the Fens | Honor |
| 1930 | Field,Rachel Rachel Field | Hitty, Her First Hundred Years | Winner |
| 1930 | Eaton,Jeanette Jeanette Eaton | Daughter of the Seine: The Life of Madame Roland,The A Daughter of the Seine: The Life of Madame Roland | Honor |
| 1930 | Miller,Elizabeth Elizabeth Miller | Pran of Albania | Honor |
| 1930 | McNeely,Marion Hurd Marion Hurd McNeely | Jumping-Off Place | Honor |
| 1930 | Young,Ella Ella Young | Tangle-Coated Horse and Other Tales,The The Tangle-Coated Horse and Other Tales | Honor |
| 1930 | Adams,Julia Davis Julia Davis Adams | Vaino, A Boy of New Finland | Honor |
| 1930 | Swift,Hildegarde Hildegarde Swift | Little Blacknose: The Story of a Pioneer | Honor |
| 1931 | Coatsworth,Elizabeth Elizabeth Coatsworth | Cat Who Went to Heaven,The The Cat Who Went to Heaven | Winner |
| 1931 | Parrish,Anne Anne Parrish | Floating Island | Honor |
| 1931 | Malkus,Alida Alida Malkus | Dark Star of Itza: The Story of A Pagan Princess,The The Dark Star of Itza: The Story of A Pagan Princess | Honor |
| 1931 | Hubbard,Ralph Ralph Hubbard | Queer Person | Honor |
| 1931 | Adams,Julie Davis Julie Davis Adams | Mountains are Free | Honor |
| 1931 | Hewes,Agnes Agnes Hewes | Spice and the Devil's Cave | Honor |
| 1931 | Gray,Elizabeth Janey Elizabeth Janet Gray | Meggy MacIntosh | Honor |
| 1931 | Best,Herbert Herbert Best | Garram the Hunter: A Boy of the Hill Tribes | Honor |
| 1931 | Lide,Alice & Margaret Johansen Alice Lide & Margaret Johansen | Ood-Le-Uk the Wanderer | Honor |
| 1932 | Armer,Laura Adams Laura Adams Armer | Waterless Mountain | Winner |
| 1932 | Lathrop,Dorothy P. Dorothy P. Lathrop | The Fairy Circus | Honor |
| 1932 | Field,Rachel Rachel Field | Calico Bush | Honor |
| 1932 | Tietjens,Eunice Eunice Tietjens | Boy of the South Seas | Honor |
| 1932 | Lownsbery,Eloise Eloise Lownsbery | Out of the Flame | Honor |
| 1932 | Allee,Marjorie Hill Marjorie Hill Allee | Jane's Island | Honor |
| 1932 | Davis,Mary Gould Mary Gould Davis | Truce of the Wolf and Other Tales of Old Italy | Honor |
| 1933 | Lewis,Elizabeth Foreman Elizabeth Foreman Lewis | Young Fu of the Upper Yangtze | Winner |
| 1933 | Meigs,Cornelia Cornelia Meigs | Swift Rivers | Honor |
| 1933 | Swift,Hildegarde Hildegarde Swift | Railroad To Freedom: A Story of the Civil War,The The Railroad To Freedom: A Story of the Civil War | Honor |
| 1933 | Burglon,Nora Nora Burglon | Children of the Soil: A Story of Scandinavia | Honor |
| 1934 | Meigs,Cornelia Cornelia Meigs | Invincible Louisa | Winner |
| 1934 | Snedeker,Caroline Caroline Snedeker | Forgotten Daughter,The The Forgotten Daughter | Honor |
| 1934 | Singmaster,Eli Elsie Singmaster | Swords of Steel | Honor |
| 1934 | Gag,Wanda Wanda Gág | ABC Bunny | Honor |
| 1934 | Berry,Erik Erik Berry | Winged Girl of Knossos | Honor |
| 1934 | Schmidt,Sarah Sarah Schmidt | New Land | Honor |
| 1934 | Colum,Padriaic Padraic Colum | Big Tree of Bunlahy: Stories of My Own Countryside | Honor |
| 1934 | Hewes,Agnes Agnes Hewes | Glory of the Seas | Honor |
| 1934 | Kyle,Ann Ann Kyle | Apprentice of Florence | Honor |
| 1935 | Shannon,Monica Monica Shannon | Dobry | Winner |
| 1935 | Seeger,Elizabeth Elizabeth Seeger | Pageant of Chinese History | Honor |
| 1935 | Rourke,Constance Constance Rourke | Davy Crockett | Honor |
| 1935 | Stockum,Hilda van Hilda van Stockum | Day On Skates: The Story of a Dutch Picnic | Honor |
| 1936 | Brink,Carol Ryrie Carol Ryrie Brink | Caddie Woodlawn | Winner |
| 1936 | Strong,Phil Phil Stong | Honk, the Moose | Honor |
| 1936 | Seredy,Kate Kate Seredy | Good Master,The The Good Master | Honor |
| 1936 | Gray,Elizabeth Janet Elizabeth Janet Gray | Young Walter Scott | Honor |
| 1936 | Sperry,Armstrong Armstrong Sperry | All Sail Set: A Romance of the Flying Cloud | Honor |
| 1937 | Sawyer,Ruth Ruth Sawyer | Roller Skates | Winner |
| 1937 | Lenski,Lois Lois Lenski | Phoebe Fairchild: Her Book | Honor |
| 1937 | Jones,Idwal Idwal Jones | Whistler's Van | Honor |
| 1937 | Bemelman,Ludwig Ludwig Bemelmans | Golden Basket,The The Golden Basket | Honor |
| 1937 | Williams,Margery Margery Williams | Winterbound | Honor |
| 1937 | Rourke,Constance Constance Rourke | Audubon Audubon | Honor |
| 1937 | Hewes, Agnes Agnes Hewes | Codfish Musket,The The Codfish Musket | Honor |
| 1938 | Seredy,Kate Kate Seredy | White Stag,The The White Stag | Winner |
| 1938 | Bowman,James Cloyd James Cloyd Bowman | Pecos Bill: The Greatest Cowboy of All Time | Honor |
| 1938 | Robinson,Mabel Mabel Robinson | Bright Island | Honor |
| 1938 | Wilder,Laura Ingalls Laura Ingalls Wilder | On the Banks of Plum Creek | Honor |
| 1939 | Enright,Elizabeth Elizabeth Enright | Thimble Summer | Winner |
| 1939 | Angelo,Valenti Valenti Angelo | Nino | Honor |
| 1939 | Atwater,Richard&Florence Richard & Florence Atwater | Mr. Popper's Penguins | Honor |
| 1939 | Crawford,Phyllis Phyllis Crawford | Hello the Boat! | Honor |
| 1939 | Eaton,Jeanette Jeanette Eaton | Leader By Destiny: George Washington, Man and Patriot | Honor |
| 1939 | Gray,Elizabeth Janet Elizabeth Janet Gray | Penn | Honor |
| 1940 | Daugherty,James James Daugherty | Daniel Boone | Winner |
| 1940 | Seredy,Kate Kate Seredy | Singing Tree,The The Singing Tree | Honor |
| 1940 | Robinson,Mabel Mabel Robinson | Runner of the Mountain Tops: The Life of Louis Agassiz | Honor |
| 1940 | Wilder,Laura Ingalls Laura Ingalls Wilder | By the Shores of Silver Lake | Honor |
| 1940 | Meader,Stephen, W. Stephen W. Meader | Boy with a Pack | Honor |
| 1941 | Sperry,Armstrong Armstrong Sperry | Call It Courage | Winner |
| 1941 | Gates,Doris Doris Gates | Blue Willow | Honor |
| 1941 | Carr,Mary Jane Mary Jane Carr | Young Mac of Fort Vancouver | Honor |
| 1941 | Wilder,Laura Ingalls Laura Ingalls Wilder | Long Winter,The The Long Winter | Honor |
| 1941 | Hall,Anna Gertrude Anna Gertrude Hall | Nansen | Honor |
| 1942 | Edmonds,Walter D. Walter D. Edmonds | Matchlock Gun,The The Matchlock Gun | Winner |
| 1942 | Wilder,Laura Ingalls Laura Ingalls Wilder | Little Town on the Prairie | Honor |
| 1942 | Foster,Genevieve Genevieve Foster | George Washington's World | Honor |
| 1942 | Lenski,Lois Lois Lenski | Indian Captive: The Story of Mary Jemison | Honor |
| 1942 | Gaggin,Eva Roe Eva Roe Gaggin | Down Ryton Water | Honor |
| 1943 | Vining,Elizabeth Gray Elizabeth Gray Vining | Adam of the Road | Winner |
| 1943 | Eleanor,Estes Eleanor Estes | Middle Moffat,The The Middle Moffat | Honor |
| 1943 | Hunt,MabelLeigh Mabel Leigh Hunt | Have You Seen Tom Thumb? | Honor |
| 1944 | Forbes,Esther Esther Forbes | Johnny Tremain | Winner |
| 1944 | Wilder,Laura Ingalls Laura Ingalls Wilder | These Happy Golden Years | Honor |
| 1944 | Saur,Julia Julia Sauer | Fog Magic | Honor |
| 1944 | Estes,Eleanor Eleanor Estes | Rufus M. | Honor |
| 1944 | Yates,Elizabeth Elizabeth Yates | Mountain Born | Honor |
| 1945 | Lawson,Robert Robert Lawson | Rabbit Hill | Winner |
| 1945 | Estes,Eleanor Eleanor Estes | Hundred Dresses,The The Hundred Dresses | Honor |
| 1945 | Dalgliesh,Alice Alice Dalgliesh | Silver Pencil,The The Silver Pencil | Honor |
| 1945 | Foster,Genevieve Genevieve Foster | Abraham Lincoln's World | Honor |
| 1945 | Eaton,Jeanette Jeanette Eaton | Lone Journey: The Life of Roger Williams | Honor |
| 1946 | Lenski,Lois Lois Lenski | Strawberry Girl | Winner |
| 1946 | Henry,Marguerite Marguerite Henry | Justin Morgan Had a Horse | Honor |
| 1946 | Means,Florence Crannell Florence Crannell Means | Moved-Outers,The The Moved-Outers | Honor |
| 1946 | Weston,Christine Christine Weston | Bhimsa, the Dancing Bear | Honor |
| 1946 | Shippen,Katherine Katherine Shippen | New Found World | Honor |
| 1947 | Bailey,Carolyn Sherwin Carolyn Sherwin Bailey | Miss Hickory | Winner |
| 1947 | Barnes,Nancy Nancy Barnes | Wonderful Year | Honor |
| 1947 | Buff,Mary %& Conrad Mary & Conrad Buff | Big Tree | Honor |
| 1947 | Maxwell,William William Maxwell | Heavenly Tenants,The The Heavenly Tenants | Honor |
| 1947 | Fisher,Cyrus Cyrus Fisher | Avion My Uncle Flew,The The Avion My Uncle Flew | Honor |
| 1947 | Jewett,Eleanor Eleanor Jewett | Hidden Treasure of Glaston,The The Hidden Treasure of Glaston | Honor |
| 1948 | Pene du Bois,William William Pène du Bois | Twenty-One Balloons,The The Twenty-One Balloons | Winner |
| 1948 | Bishop,Claire Huchet Claire Huchet Bishop | Pancakes-Paris | Honor |
| 1948 | Treffinger,Carolyn Carolyn Treffinger | Li Lun, Lad of Courage | Honor |
| 1948 | Besterman,Catherine Catherine Besterman | Quaint and Curious Quest of Johnny Longfoot,The The Quaint and Curious Quest of Johnny Longfoot | Honor |
| 1948 | Courlander,Harold Harold Courlander | Cow-Tail Switch, and Other West African Stories,The The Cow-Tail Switch, and Other West African Stories | Honor |
| 1948 | Henry,Marguerite Marguerite Henry | Misty of Chincoteague | Honor |
| 1949 | Henry,Marguerite Marguerite Henry | King of the Wind | Winner |
| 1949 | Holling,Holling C. Holling C. Holling | Seabird | Honor |
| 1949 | Rankin,Louise Louise Rankin | Daughter of the Mountain | Honor |
| 1949 | Gannett,Ruth S. Ruth S. Gannett | My Father's Dragon | Honor |
| 1949 | Bontemps,Arna Arna Bontemps | Story of the Negro | Honor |
| 1950 | Angeli,Marguerite de Marguerite de Angeli | Door in the Wall The Door in the Wall | Winner |
| 1950 | Caudill,Rebecca Rebecca Caudill | Tree of Freedom | Honor |
| 1950 | Coblentz,Catherine Catherine Coblentz | Blue Cat of Castle Town,The The Blue Cat of Castle Town | Honor |
| 1950 | Montgomer,Rutherford Rutherford Montgomery | Kildee House | Honor |
| 1950 | Foster,Genevieve Genevieve Foster | George Washington | Honor |
| 1950 | Havighurst,Walter & Marion Walter & Marion Havighurst | Song of The Pines: A Story of Norwegian Lumbering in Wisconsin | Honor |
| 1951 | Yates,Elizabeth Elizabeth Yates | Amos Fortune, Free Man | Winner |
| 1951 | Hunt,Mabel Leigh Mabel Leigh Hunt | Better Known as Johnny Appleseed | Honor |
| 1951 | Easton,Jeanette Jeanette Eaton | Gandhi, Fighter Without a Sword | Honor |
| 1951 | Judson,Clara Ingram Clara Ingram Judson | Abraham Lincoln, Friend of the People | Honor |
| 1951 | Parrish,Anne Anne Parrish | Story of Appleby Capple,The The Story of Appleby Capple | Honor |
| 1952 | Estes,Eleanor Eleanor Estes | Ginger Pye | Winner |
| 1952 | Baity,Elizabeth Elizabeth Baity | Americans Before Columbus | Honor |
| 1952 | Holling,Holling C. Holling C. Holling | Minn of the Mississippi | Honor |
| 1952 | Kalashnikoff,Nicholas Nicholas Kalashnikoff | Defender,The The Defender | Honor |
| 1952 | Saur,Julia Julia Sauer | Light at Tern Rock,The The Light at Tern Rock | Honor |
| 1952 | Buff,Mary & Conrad Mary & Conrad Buff | Apple and the Arrow,The The Apple and the Arrow | Honor |
| 1953 | Clark,Ann Nolan Ann Nolan Clark | Secret of the Andes | Winner |
| 1953 | White,E. B. E. B. White | Charlotte's Web | Honor |
| 1953 | McGraw,Eloise Jarvis Eloise Jarvis McGraw | Moccasin Trail | Honor |
| 1953 | Weil,Ann Ann Weil | Red Sails to Capri | Honor |
| 1953 | Dalgliesch,Alice Alice Dalgliesh | Bears on Hemlock Mountain,The The Bears on Hemlock Mountain | Honor |
| 1953 | Foster,Genevieve Genevieve Foster | 'Birthdays of Freedom, Vol. 1 | Honor |
| 1954 | Krumgold,Joseph Joseph Krumgold | And Now Miguel ...And Now Miguel | Winner |
| 1954 | Bishop,Claire Huchet Claire Huchet Bishop | All Alone | Honor |
| 1954 | DeJong,Meindert Meindert DeJong | Shadrach | Honor |
| 1954 | DeJong,Meindert Meindert DeJong | Hurry Home, Candy | Honor |
| 1954 | Judson,Clar Ingram Clara Ingram Judson | Theodore Roosevelt, Fighting Patriot | Honor |
| 1954 | Buff,Mary & Conrad Mary & Conrad Buff | Magic Maize | Honor |
| 1955 | DeJong,Meindert Meindert DeJong | Wheel on the School,The The Wheel on the School | Winner |
| 1955 | Dalgliesh,Alice Alice Dalgliesh | Courage of Sarah Noble The Courage of Sarah Noble | Honor |
| 1955 | Ullman,James James Ullman | Banner in the Sky | Honor |
| 1956 | Latham,Jean Lee Jean Lee Latham | Carry On, Mr. Bowditch | Winner |
| 1956 | Rawlings,Marjorie Kinnan Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings | Secret River,The The Secret River | Honor |
| 1956 | Lindquist,Jennie Jennie Lindquist | Golden Name Day,The The Golden Name Day | Honor |
| 1956 | Shippen,Katherine Katherine Shippen | Men, Microscopes, and Living Things | Honor |
| 1957 | Sorensen,Virginia Virginia Sorensen | Miracles on Maple Hill | Winner |
| 1957 | Gipson,Fred Fred Gipson | Old Yeller | Honor |
| 1957 | DeJong,Meindert Meindert DeJong | House of Sixty Fathers,The The House of Sixty Fathers | Honor |
| 1957 | Judson,Clara Ingram Clara Ingram Judson | Mr. Justice Holmes | Honor |
| 1957 | Rhoads,Dorothy Dorothy Rhoads | Corn Grows Ripe,The The Corn Grows Ripe | Honor |
| 1957 | Angeli,Marguerite de Marguerite de Angeli | Black Fox of Lorne | Honor |
| 1958 | Keith,Harold Harold Keith | Rifles for Watie | Winner |
| 1958 | Sandoz,Mari Mari Sandoz | Horsecatcher,The The Horsecatcher | Honor |
| 1958 | Enright,Elizabeth Elizabeth Enright | Gone-Away Lake | Honor |
| 1958 | Lawson,Robert Robert Lawson | Great Wheel,The The Great Wheel | Honor |
| 1958 | Gurko,Leo Leo Gurko | Tom Paine, Freedom's Apostle | Honor |
| 1959 | Speare,Elizabeth George Elizabeth George Speare | Witch of Blackbird Pond,The The Witch of Blackbird Pond | Winner |
| 1959 | Carlson,Natalie Savage Natalie Savage Carlson | Family Under The Bridge,The The Family Under The Bridge | Honor |
| 1959 | DeJong,Meindert Meindert DeJong | Along Came A Dog | Honor |
| 1959 | Kalnay,Francis Francis Kalnay | Chucaro: Wild Pony of the Pampa | Honor |
| 1959 | Steele,William O. William O. Steele | Perilous Road,The The Perilous Road | Honor |
| 1960 | Krumgold,Joseph Joseph Krumgold | Onion John | Winner |
| 1960 | George,Jean Craighead Jean Craighead George | My Side of the Mountain | Honor |
| 1960 | Johnson,Gerald W. Gerald W. Johnson | America Is Born: A History for Peter | Honor |
| 1960 | Kendall,Carol Carol Kendall | Gammage Cup,The The Gammage Cup | Honor |
| 1961 | O'Dell,Scott Scott O'Dell | Island of the Blue Dolphins | Winner |
| 1961 | Johnson,Gerald W. Gerald W. Johnson | America Moves Forward: A History for Peter | Honor |
| 1961 | Schaefer,Jack Jack Schaefer | Old Ramon | Honor |
| 1961 | Selden,George George Selden | Cricket in Times Square,The The Cricket in Times Square | Honor |
| 1962 | Speare,Elizabeth George Elizabeth George Speare | Bronze Bow,The The Bronze Bow | Winner |
| 1962 | Tunis,Edwin Edwin Tunis | Frontier Living | Honor |
| 1962 | McGraw,Eloise Jarvis Eloise Jarvis McGraw | Golden Goblet,The The Golden Goblet | Honor |
| 1962 | Stoltz,Mary Mary Stolz | Belling The Tiger | Honor |
| 1963 | L'Engle,Madeleine Madeleine L'Engle | Wrinkle in Time,A A Wrinkle in Time | Winner |
| 1963 | Leodhas,Sorche Nic Sorche Nic Leodhas | Thistle and Thyme: Tales and Legends from Scotland | Honor |
| 1963 | Coolidge,Olivia Olivia Coolidge | Men of Athens | Honor |
| 1964 | Neville,Emily Cheney Emily Cheney Neville | It's Like This, Cat | Winner |
| 1964 | North,Sterling Sterling North | Rascal | Honor |
| 1964 | Wier,Ester Ester Wier | Loner,The The Loner | Honor |
| 1965 | Wojciechowska,Maia Maia Wojciechowska | Shadow of a Bull | Winner |
| 1965 | Hunt,Irene Irene Hunt | Across Five Aprils | Honor |
| 1966 | Trevino,Elizabeth Borton de Elizabeth Borton de Treviño | I, Juan de Pareja | Winner |
| 1966 | Alexander,Lloyd Lloyd Alexander | Black Cauldron,The The Black Cauldron | Honor |
| 1966 | Jarrell,Randall Randall Jarrell | Animal Family,The The Animal Family | Honor |
| 1966 | Stolz,Mary Mary Stolz | Noonday Friends,The The Noonday Friends | Honor |
| 1967 | Hunt,Irene Irene Hunt | Up a Road Slowly | Winner |
| 1967 | Odell,Scott Scott O'Dell | King's Fifth,The The King's Fifth | Honor |
| 1967 | Singer,Isaac Bashevis Isaac Bashevis Singer | Zlateh The Goat and Other Stories | Honor |
| 1967 | Weik,Mary Hays Mary Hays Weik | Jazz Man,The The Jazz Man | Honor |
| 1968 | Konigsburg,E. L. E. L. Konigsburg | From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler | Winner |
| 1968 | Konigsburg,EL E. L. Konigsburg | Jennifer, Hecate, Macbeth, William McKinley, and Me, Elizabeth | Honor |
| 1968 | Odell,Scott Scott O'Dell | Black Pearl,The The Black Pearl | Honor |
| 1968 | Singer,Isaac Bashevis Isaac Bashevis Singer | Fearsome Inn,The The Fearsome Inn | Honor |
| 1968 | Snyder,Zilpha Keatley Zilpha Keatley Snyder | Egypt Game,The The Egypt Game | Honor |
| 1969 | Alexander,Lloyd Lloyd Alexander | High King,The The High King | Winner |
| 1969 | Lester,Julius Julius Lester | To Be a Slave | Honor |
| 1969 | Singer,Isaac Bashevis Isaac Bashevis Singer | When Shlemiel Went to Warsaw and Other Stories | Honor |
| 1970 | Armstron,William H. William H. Armstrong | Sounder | Winner |
| 1970 | Ish-Kishor,Sulamith Sulamith Ish-Kishor | Our Eddie | Honor |
| 1970 | Moore,Janet Gaylord Janet Gaylord Moore | Many Ways of Seeing: An Introduction to the Pleasures of Art,The The Many Ways of Seeing: An Introduction to the Pleasures of Art | Honor |
| 1970 | Steele,Mary Q. Mary Q. Steele | Journey Outside | Honor |
| 1971 | Byars,Betsy Betsy Byars | Summer of the Swans | Winner |
| 1971 | Babbitt,Natalie Natalie Babbitt | Knee-Knock Rise | Honor |
| 1971 | Engdahl,Sylvia Sylvia Engdahl | Enchantress From the Stars | Honor |
| 1971 | Odell,Scott Scott O'Dell | Sing Down the Moon | Honor |
| 1972 | O'Brien,Robert C. Robert C. O'Brien | Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH | Winner |
| 1972 | Eckert,Allan W. Allan W. Eckert | Incident At Hawk's Hill | Honor |
| 1972 | Hamilton,Virginia Virginia Hamilton | The Planet of Junior Brown | Honor |
| 1972 | Le Guin,Ursula K. Ursula K. Le Guin | Tombs of Atuan,The The Tombs of Atuan | Honor |
| 1972 | Miles,Miska Miska Miles | Annie and the Old One | Honor |
| 1972 | Snyder,Zilpha Keatley Zilpha Keatley Snyder | Headless Cupid,The The Headless Cupid | Honor |
| 1973 | George,Jean Craighead Jean Craighead George | Julie of the Wolves | Winner |
| 1973 | Lobel,Arnold Arnold Lobel | Frog and Toad Together | Honor |
| 1973 | Reiss,Johanna Johanna Reiss | Upstairs Room,The The Upstairs Room | Honor |
| 1973 | Snyder,Zilpha Keatley Zilpha Keatley Snyder | Witches of Worm,The The Witches of Worm | Honor |
| 1974 | Fox,Paula Paula Fox | Slave Dancer,The The Slave Dancer | Winner |
| 1974 | Cooper,Susan Susan Cooper | Dark Is Rising,The The Dark Is Rising | Honor |
| 1975 | Hamilton,Virginia Virginia Hamilton | M. C. Higgins, the Great | Winner |
| 1975 | Raskin,Ellen Ellen Raskin | Figgs & Phantoms | Honor |
| 1975 | Collier,James Lincoln and Christopher Collier James Lincoln Collier & Christopher Collier | My Brother Sam Is Dead | Honor |
| 1975 | Pope,Elizabeth Marier Elizabeth Marie Pope | Perilous Gard,The The Perilous Gard | Honor |
| 1975 | Greene,Bette Bette Greene | Philip Hall Likes Me, I Reckon Maybe | Honor |
| 1976 | Cooper,Susan Susan Cooper | Grey King,The The Grey King | Winner |
| 1976 | Mathis,Sharon Bell Sharon Bell Mathis | Hundred Penny Box,The The Hundred Penny Box | Honor |
| 1976 | Yep,Laurence Laurence Yep | Dragonwings | Honor |
| 1977 | Taylor,Mildred Mildred Taylor | Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry | Winner |
| 1977 | Steig,William William Steig | Abel's Island | Honor |
| 1977 | Bond,Nancy Nancy Bond | String in the Harp,A A String in the Harp | Honor |
| 1978 | Paterson,Katherine Katherine Paterson | Bridge to Terabithia | Winner |
| 1978 | Cleary,Beverly Beverly Cleary | Ramona and Her Father | Honor |
| 1978 | Highwater,Jamake Jamake Highwater | 'Anpao: An American Indian Odyssey | Honor |
| 1979 | Raskin,Ellen Ellen Raskin | Westing Game,The The Westing Game | Winner |
| 1979 | Paterson,Katherine Katherine Paterson | Great Gilly Hopkins,The The Great Gilly Hopkins | Honor |
| 1980 | Blos,Joan Joan Blos | Gathering of Days: A New England Girl's Journal,A A Gathering of Days: A New England Girl's Journal | Winner |
| 1980 | Kherdian,David David Kherdian | Road from Home: The Story of an Armenian Girl,The The Road from Home: The Story of an Armenian Girl | Honor |
| 1981 | Paterson,Katherine Katherine Paterson | Jacob Have I Loved | Winner |
| 1981 | Langton,Jane Jane Langton | Fledgling,The The Fledgling | Honor |
| 1981 | LEngle,Madeleine Madeleine L'Engle | Ring of Endless Light,A A Ring of Endless Light | Honor |
| 1982 | Willard,Nancy Nancy Willard | Visit to William Blake's Inn,A A Visit to William Blake's Inn | Winner |
| 1982 | Cleary,Beverly Beverly Cleary | Ramona Quimby, Age 8 | Honor |
| 1982 | Siegal,Aranka Aranka Siegal | Upon the Head of the Goat: A Childhood in Hungary 1939-1944 | Honor |
| 1982 | McKinley,Robin Robin McKinley | Blue Sword,The The Blue Sword | Honor |
| 1983 | Voigt,Cynthia Cynthia Voigt | Dicey's Song | Winner |
| 1983 | Steig,William William Steig | Doctor De Soto | Honor |
| 1983 | Fleischman,Paul Paul Fleischman | Graven Images | Honor |
| 1983 | Fritz,Jean Jean Fritz | Homesick: My Own Story | Honor |
| 1983 | Hamilton,Virginia Virginia Hamilton | Sweet Whispers, Brother Rush | Honor |
| 1984 | Cleary, Beverly Beverly Cleary | Dear Mr. Henshaw | Winner |
| 1984 | Speare,Elizabeth George Elizabeth George Speare | Sign of the Beaver,The The Sign of the Beaver | Honor |
| 1984 | Voigt,Cynthia Cynthia Voigt | Solitary Blue,A A Solitary Blue | Honor |
| 1984 | Lasky,Kathryn Kathryn Lasky | Sugaring Time | Honor |
| 1984 | Brittain,Bill Bill Brittain | Wish Giver,The The Wish Giver | Honor |
| 1985 | McKinley,Robin Robin McKinley | Hero and the Crown,The The Hero and the Crown | Winner |
| 1985 | Jukes,Mavis Mavis Jukes | Like Jake and Me | Honor |
| 1985 | Brooks,Bruce Bruce Brooks | Moves Make the Man,The The Moves Make the Man | Honor |
| 1985 | Fox,Paula Paula Fox | One-Eyed Cat | Honor |
| 1986 | MacLachlan,Patricia Patricia MacLachlan | Sarah, Plain and Tall | Winner |
| 1986 | Blumberg,Rhoda Rhoda Blumberg | Commodore Perry In the Land of the Shogun | Honor |
| 1986 | Paulsen,Gary Gary Paulsen | Dogsong | Honor |
| 1987 | Fleischman,Sid Sid Fleischman | Whipping Boy,The The Whipping Boy | Winner |
| 1987 | Rylant,Cynthia Cynthia Rylant | Fine White Dust,A A Fine White Dust | Honor |
| 1987 | Bauer,Marion Dane Marion Dane Bauer | On My Honor | Honor |
| 1987 | Lauber,Patricia Patricia Lauber | Volcano: The Eruption and Healing of Mount St. Helens | Honor |
| 1988 | Freedman,Russell Russell Freedman | Lincoln: A Photobiography | Winner |
| 1988 | Mazer,Norma Fox Norma Fox Mazer | After the Rain | Honor |
| 1988 | Paulsen,Gary Gary Paulsen | Hatchet | Honor |
| 1989 | Fleischman,Paul Paul Fleischman | Joyful Noise: Poems for Two Voices | Winner |
| 1989 | Hamilton,Virginia Virginia Hamilton | In The Beginning: Creation Stories from Around the World | Honor |
| 1989 | Myers,Walter Dean Walter Dean Myers | Scorpions | Honor |
| 1990 | Lowry,Lois Lois Lowry | Number the Stars | Winner |
| 1990 | Lislie,Janey Taylor Janet Taylor Lisle | Afternoon of the Elves | Honor |
| 1990 | Staples,Suzanne Fisher Suzanne Fisher Staples | Shabanu, Daughter of the Wind | Honor |
| 1990 | Paulsen,Gary Gary Paulsen | Winter Room,The The Winter Room | Honor |
| 1991 | Spinelli,Jerry Jerry Spinelli | Maniac Magee | Winner |
| 1991 | Avi | True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle,The The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle | Honor |
| 1992 | Naylor,Phyllis Reynolds Phyllis Reynolds Naylor | Shiloh | Winner |
| 1992 | Avi | Nothing But The Truth: a Documentary Novel | Honor |
| 1992 | Freedman,Russell Russell Freedman | Wright Brothers: How They Invented the Airplane,The The Wright Brothers: How They Invented the Airplane | Honor |
| 1993 | Rylant,Cynthia Cynthia Rylant | Missing May | Winner |
| 1993 | Brooks, Bruce Bruce Brooks | What Hearts | Honor |
| 1993 | McKissack,Patricia Patricia McKissack | Dark-thirty: Southern Tales of the Supernatural,The The Dark-thirty: Southern Tales of the Supernatural | Honor |
| 1993 | Myers,Walter Dean Walter Dean Myers | Somewhere in the Darkness | Honor |
| 1994 | Lowry,Lois Lois Lowry | Giver,The The Giver | Winner |
| 1994 | Conly,Jane Leslie Jane Leslie Conly | Crazy Lady | Honor |
| 1994 | Yep,Laurence Laurence Yep | Dragon's Gate | Honor |
| 1994 | Freedman,Russell Russell Freedman | Eleanor Roosevelt: A Life of Discovery | Honor |
| 1995 | Creech,Sharon Sharon Creech | Walk Two Moons | Winner |
| 1995 | Cushman,Karen Karen Cushman | Catherine, Called Birdy | Honor |
| 1995 | Farmer,Nancy Nancy Farmer | Ear, the Eye and the Arm,The The Ear, the Eye and the Arm | Honor |
| 1996 | Cushman,Karen Karen Cushman | Midwife's Apprentice,The The Midwife's Apprentice | Winner |
| 1996 | Coman,Carolyn Carolyn Coman | What Jamie Saw | Honor |
| 1996 | Curtis,Christopher Paul Christopher Paul Curtis | Watsons Go to Birmingham: 1963,The The Watsons Go to Birmingham: 1963 | Honor |
| 1996 | Fenner,Carol Carol Fenner | Yolonda's Genius | Honor |
| 1996 | Murphy,Jim Jim Murphy | Great Fire,The The Great Fire | Honor |
| 1997 | Konigsburg,E. L. E. L. Konigsburg | View from Saturday,The The View from Saturday | Winner |
| 1997 | Farmer,Nancy Nancy Farmer | Girl Named Disaster,A A Girl Named Disaster | Honor |
| 1997 | McGraw,Eloise Eloise McGraw | Moorchild,The The Moorchild | Honor |
| 1997 | Turner, Megan Whalen Megan Whalen Turner | Thief,The The Thief | Honor |
| 1997 | White,Ruth Ruth White | Belle Prater's Boy | Honor |
| 1998 | Hesse,Karen Karen Hesse | Out of the Dust | Winner |
| 1998 | Levine,Gail Carson Gail Carson Levine | Ella Enchanted | Honor |
| 1998 | Giff,Patricia Reilly Patricia Reilly Giff | Lily's Crossing | Honor |
| 1998 | Spinelli,Jerry Jerry Spinelli | Wringer | Honor |
| 1999 | Sachar,Louis Louis Sachar | Holes | Winner |
| 1999 | Peck,Richard Richard Peck | Long Way from Chicago,A A Long Way from Chicago | Honor |
| 2000 | Curtis,Christopher Paul Christopher Paul Curtis | Bud, Not Buddy | Winner |
| 2000 | Couloumbis,Audrey Audrey Couloumbis | Getting Near to Baby | Honor |
| 2000 | Holm,Jennifer L. Jennifer L. Holm | Our Only May Amelia | Honor |
| 2000 | Paola,Tomie de Tomie dePaola | 26 Fairmount Avenue | Honor |
| 2001 | Peck,Richard Richard Peck | Year Down Yonder,A A Year Down Yonder | Winner |
| 2001 | Bauer,Joan Joan Bauer | Hope Was Here | Honor |
| 2001 | DiCamillo,Kate Kate DiCamillo | Because of Winn-Dixie | Honor |
| 2001 | Gantos,Jack Jack Gantos | Joey Pigza Loses Control | Honor |
| 2001 | Creech,Sharon Sharon Creech | Wanderer,The The Wanderer | Honor |
| 2002 | Park,Linda Sue Linda Sue Park | Single Shard,A A Single Shard | Winner |
| 2002 | Horvath,Polly Polly Horvath | Everything on a Waffle | Honor |
| 2002 | Nelson,Marilyn Marilyn Nelson | Carver: A Life In Poems | Honor |
| 2003 | Avi Avi | Crispin: The Cross of Lead | Winner |
| 2003 | Farmer,Nancy Nancy Farmer | House of the Scorpion,The The House of the Scorpion | Honor |
| 2003 | Giff,Patricia Reilly Patricia Reilly Giff | Pictures of Hollis Woods | Honor |
| 2003 | Hiaasen,Carl Carl Hiaasen | Hoot | Honor |
| 2003 | Martin,Ann M. Ann M. Martin | Corner of the Universe,A A Corner of the Universe | Honor |
| 2003 | Tolan,Stephanie S. Stephanie S. Tolan | Surviving the Applewhites | Honor |
| 2004 | DiCamillo,Kate Kate DiCamillo | Tale of Despereaux,The The Tale of Despereaux | Winner |
| 2004 | Henkes,Kevin Kevin Henkes | Olive's Ocean | Honor |
| 2004 | Murphy,Jim Jim Murphy | American Plague: The True and Terrifying Story of the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793,An An American Plague: The True and Terrifying Story of the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793 | Honor |
| 2005 | Kadohata,Cynthia Cynthia Kadohata | Kira-Kira | Winner |
| 2005 | Choldenko,Gennifer Gennifer Choldenko | Al Capone Does My Shirts | Honor |
| 2005 | Freedman,Russell Russell Freedman | Voice that Challenged a Nation: Marian Anderson and the Struggle for Equal Rights,The The Voice that Challenged a Nation: Marian Anderson and the Struggle for Equal Rights | Honor |
| 2005 | Schmidt,Gary D. Gary D. Schmidt | Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy | Honor |
| 2006 | Perkins,Lynne Rae Lynne Rae Perkins | Criss Cross | Winner |
| 2006 | Armstron,Alan Alan Armstrong | Whittington | Honor |
| 2006 | Bartoletti,Susan Campbell Susan Campbell Bartoletti | Hitler Youth: Growing Up in Hitler's Shadow | Honor |
| 2006 | Hale,Shannon Shannon Hale | Princess Academy | Honor |
| 2006 | Woodson,Jacqueline Jacqueline Woodson | Show Way | Honor |
| 2007 | Patron,Susan Susan Patron | Higher Power of Lucky,The The Higher Power of Lucky | Winner |
| 2007 | Holm,Jennifer L. Jennifer L. Holm | Penny from Heaven | Honor |
| 2007 | Larson,Kirby Kirby Larson | Hattie Big Sky | Honor |
| 2007 | Lord,Cynthia Cynthia Lord | Rules | Honor |
| 2008 | Schlitz,Laura Amy Laura Amy Schlitz | Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! Voices from a Medieval Village | Winner |
| 2008 | Curtis,Christopher Paul Christopher Paul Curtis | Elijah of Buxton | Honor |
| 2008 | Schmidt,Gary D. Gary D. Schmidt | Wednesday Wars,The The Wednesday Wars | Honor |
| 2008 | Woodson,Jacqueline Jacqueline Woodson | Feathers Feathers | Honor |
| 2009 | Gaiman,Neil Neil Gaiman | Graveyard Book,The The Graveyard Book | Winner |
| 2009 | Appelt,Kathi Kathi Appelt | Underneath,The The Underneath | Honor |
| 2009 | Engle,Margarita Margarita Engle | Surrender Tree: Poems of Cuba's Struggle for Freedom,The The Surrender Tree: Poems of Cuba's Struggle for Freedom | Honor |
| 2009 | Law,Ingrid Ingrid Law | Savvy Savvy | Honor |
| 2009 | Woodson,Jacqueline Jacqueline Woodson | After Tupac & D Foster | Honor |