Scoring five goals in a single NHL game is an extremely rare feat which has only been accomplished 59 times. One player—Joe Malone—has scored seven goals in a game, seven players have scored six goals in a game, and 39 have scored five goals in a game. Only two players have scored six goals or more after 1967. Joe Malone—ranked second for most career goals of any player in major hockey's first half-century—scored five goals in a game on five separate occasions, of which one was a six-goal game, and another an NHL-record seven-goal game.[3] Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux each attained the feat four times while five other players have also had multiple five-goal game. There have been exactly five instances of five goals being scored in a playoff game.[4] Mario Lemieux is the only player in history to score five goals in five different ways during a game. On December 31, 1988, he scored an even-strength goal, a power-play goal, a short handed goal, a penalty shot goal and an empty net goal.[5]
| Name | Nationality | Team | Date | Goals |
| Malone, JoeJoe Malone | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01917-12-19 December 19, 1917 | 5 |
| Hyland, HarryHarry Hyland | Canada | Montreal Wanderers | 01917-12-19 December 19, 1917 | 5 |
| Malone, JoeJoe Malone | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01918-01-12 January 12, 1918 | 5 |
| Malone, JoeJoe Malone | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01918-02-02 February 2, 1918 | 5 |
| Lalonde, NewsyNewsy Lalonde[4] | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01919-03-01 March 1, 1919 | 5 |
| Lalonde, NewsyNewsy Lalonde | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01920-01-10 January 10, 1920 | 6 |
| Malone, JoeJoe Malone | Canada | Quebec Bulldogs | 01920-01-31 January 31, 1920 | 7 |
| Roach, MickeyMickey Roach | United States | Toronto St. Pats | 01920-03-06 March 6, 1920 | 5 |
| Malone, JoeJoe Malone | Canada | Quebec Bulldogs | 01920-03-10 March 10, 1920 | 6 |
| Denneny, CorbCorb Denneny | Canada | Toronto St. Pats | 01921-01-26 January 26, 1921 | 6 |
| Lalonde, NewsyNewsy Lalonde | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01921-02-16 February 16, 1921 | 5 |
| Denneny, CyCy Denneny | Canada | Ottawa Senators | 01921-03-07 March 7, 1921 | 6 |
| Dye, BabeBabe Dye | Canada | Toronto St. Pats | 01922-12-16 December 16, 1922 | 5 |
| Green, RedRed Green | Canada | Hamilton Tigers | 01924-12-05 December 5, 1924 | 5 |
| Dye, BabeBabe Dye | Canada | Toronto St. Pats | 01924-12-22 December 22, 1924 | 5 |
| Broadbent, PunchPunch Broadbent | Canada | Montreal Maroons | 01925-01-07 January 7, 1925 | 5 |
| Lepine, PitPit Lepine | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01929-12-29 December 29, 1929 | 5 |
| Morenz, HowieHowie Morenz | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01930-03-18 March 18, 1930 | 5 |
| Conacher, CharlieCharlie Conacher | Canada | Toronto Maple Leafs | 01932-01-19 January 19, 1932 | 5 |
| Getliffe, RayRay Getliffe | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01943-02-06 February 6, 1943 | 5 |
| Howe, SydSyd Howe | Canada | Detroit Red Wings | 01944-02-03 February 3, 1944 | 6 |
| Richard, MauriceMaurice Richard[6] | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01944-03-23 March 23, 1944 | 5 |
| Richard, MauriceMaurice Richard | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01944-12-28 December 28, 1944 | 5 |
| Meeker, HowieHowie Meeker | Canada | Toronto Maple Leafs | 01947-01-08 January 8, 1947 | 5 |
| Geoffrion, BernieBernie Geoffrion | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01955-02-19 February 19, 1955 | 5 |
| Rousseau, BobbyBobby Rousseau | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01964-02-01 February 1, 1964 | 5 |
| Berenson, RedRed Berenson | Canada | St. Louis Blues | 01968-11-07 November 7, 1968 | 6 |
| Cournoyer, YvanYvan Cournoyer | Canada | Montreal Canadiens | 01975-02-15 February 15, 1975 | 5 |
| Sittler, DarrylDarryl Sittler | Canada | Toronto Maple Leafs | 01976-02-07 February 7, 1976 | 6 |
| Sittler, DarrylDarryl Sittler[6] | Canada | Toronto Maple Leafs | 01976-04-22 April 22, 1976 | 5 |
| Leach, ReggieReggie Leach[6] | Canada | Philadelphia Flyers | 01976-05-06 May 6, 1976 | 5 |
| Murdoch, DonDon Murdoch | Canada | New York Rangers | 01976-10-12 October 12, 1976 | 5 |
| Turnbull, IanIan Turnbull | Canada | Toronto Maple Leafs | 01977-02-02 February 2, 1977 | 5 |
| Trottier, BryanBryan Trottier | Canada | New York Islanders | 01978-12-23 December 23, 1978 | 5 |
| Young, TimTim Young | Canada | Minnesota North Stars | 01979-01-15 January 15, 1979 | 5 |
| Tonelli, JohnJohn Tonelli | Canada | New York Islanders | 01981-01-06 January 6, 1981 | 5 |
| Gretzky, WayneWayne Gretzky | Canada | Edmonton Oilers | 01981-02-18 February 18, 1981 | 5 |
| Gretzky, WayneWayne Gretzky | Canada | Edmonton Oilers | 01981-12-30 December 30, 1981 | 5 |
| Mulvey, GrantGrant Mulvey | Canada | Chicago Black Hawks | 01982-02-03 February 3, 1982 | 5 |
| Trottier, BryanBryan Trottier | Canada | New York Islanders | 01982-02-12 February 12, 1982 | 5 |
| Lindstrom, WillyWilly Lindstrom | Sweden | Winnipeg Jets | 01982-03-02 March 2, 1982 | 5 |
| Pavelich, MarkMark Pavelich | United States | New York Rangers | 01983-02-23 February 23, 1983 | 5 |
| Kurri, JariJari Kurri | Finland | Edmonton Oilers | 01983-11-19 November 19, 1983 | 5 |
| Gustafsson, Bengt-AkeBengt-Ake Gustafsson | Sweden | Washington Capitals | 01984-01-08 January 8, 1984 | 5 |
| Hughes, PatPat Hughes | Canada | Edmonton Oilers | 01984-02-03 February 3, 1984 | 5 |
| Gretzky, WayneWayne Gretzky | Canada | Edmonton Oilers | 01984-12-15 December 15, 1984 | 5 |
| Andreychuk, DaveDave Andreychuk | Canada | Buffalo Sabres | 01986-02-06 February 6, 1986 | 5 |
| Gretzky, WayneWayne Gretzky | Canada | Edmonton Oilers | 01987-12-06 December 6, 1987 | 5 |
| Lemieux, MarioMario Lemieux | Canada | Pittsburgh Penguins | 01988-12-31 December 31, 1988 | 5 |
| Lemieux, MarioMario Lemieux[6] | Canada | Pittsburgh Penguins | 01989-04-25 April 25, 1989 | 5 |
| Nieuwendyk, JoeJoe Nieuwendyk | Canada | Calgary Flames | 01989-01-11 January 11, 1989 | 5 |
| Sundin, MatsMats Sundin | Sweden | Quebec Nordiques | 01992-03-05 March 5, 1992 | 5 |
| Lemieux, MarioMario Lemieux | Canada | Pittsburgh Penguins | 01993-04-09 April 9, 1993 | 5 |
| Bondra, PeterPeter Bondra | Slovakia | Washington Capitals | 01994-02-05 February 5, 1994 | 5 |
| Ricci, MikeMike Ricci | Canada | Quebec Nordiques | 01994-02-17 February 17, 1994 | 5 |
| Zhamnov, AlexeiAlexei Zhamnov | Russia | Winnipeg Jets | 01995-04-01 April 1, 1995 | 5 |
| Lemieux, MarioMario Lemieux | Canada | Pittsburgh Penguins | 01996-03-26 March 26, 1996 | 5 |
| Fedorov, SergeiSergei Fedorov | Russia | Detroit Red Wings | 01996-12-26 December 26, 1996 | 5 |
| Gaborik, MarianMarian Gaborik[7] | Slovakia | Minnesota Wild | 02007-12-20 December 20, 2007 | 5 |