| Year[A] | Pick | Player name | Position | College | Notes |
| 1967 | &0000000000000026.00000026 | Kelley, LeslieLeslie Kelley | Running back | Alabama | [a] |
| 1968 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Hardy, KevinKevin Hardy | Defensive end | Notre Dame | [b] |
| 1969 | &0000000000000017.00000017 | Shinners, JohnJohn Shinners | Guard | Xavier | [c] |
| 1970 | &0000000000000010.00000010 | Burrough, KenKen Burrough | Wide receiver | Texas Southern | |
| 1971 | &0000000000000002.0000002 | Manning, ArchieArchie Manning | Quarterback | Mississippi | |
| 1972 | &0000000000000008.0000008 | Smith, RoyceRoyce Smith | Guard | Georgia | |
| 1973 | — | — No pick | — | — | [d] |
| 1974 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Middleton, RickRick Middleton | Linebacker | Ohio State | [e] |
| 1975 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Larry Burton | Wide receiver | Purdue | |
| 1975 | &0000000000000012.00000012 | Schumacher, KurtKurt Schumacher | Offensive tackle | Ohio State | [f] |
| 1976 | &0000000000000003.0000003 | Muncie, ChuckChuck Muncie | Running back | California | |
| 1977 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Campbell, JoeJoe Campbell | Defensive end | Maryland | |
| 1978 | &0000000000000003.0000003 | Chandler, WesWes Chandler | Wide receiver | Florida | |
| 1979 | &0000000000000011.00000011 | Erxleben, RussellRussell Erxleben | Placekicker | Texas | |
| 1980 | &0000000000000012.00000012 | Brock, StanStan Brock | Offensive tackle | Colorado | |
| 1981 | &0000000000000001.0000001 | Rogers, GeorgeGeorge Rogers * | Running back | South Carolina | |
| 1982 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Scott, LindsayLindsay Scott | Wide receiver | Georgia | [g] |
| 1983 | — | — No pick | — | — | [h] |
| 1984 | — | — No pick | — | — | [i] |
| 1985 | &0000000000000024.00000024 | Toles, AlvinAlvin Toles | Linebacker | Tennessee | [j] |
| 1986 | &0000000000000006.0000006 | Dombrowski, JimJim Dombrowski | Offensive tackle | Virginia | [k] |
| 1987 | &0000000000000011.00000011 | Knight, ShawnShawn Knight | Defensive tackle | Brigham Young | |
| 1988 | &0000000000000024.00000024 | Heyward, CraigCraig Heyward | Running back | Pittsburgh | |
| 1989 | &0000000000000019.00000019 | Martin, WayneWayne Martin | Defensive end | Arkansas | |
| 1990 | &0000000000000014.00000014 | Turnbull, RenaldoRenaldo Turnbull | Defensive end | West Virginia | |
| 1991 | — | — No pick | — | — | [l] |
| 1992 | &0000000000000021.00000021 | Dunbar, VaughnVaughn Dunbar | Running back | Indiana | |
| 1993 | &0000000000000008.0000008 | Roaf, WillieWillie Roaf | Offensive tackle | Louisiana Tech | [m] |
| 1993 | &0000000000000020.00000020 | Smith, IrvIrv Smith | Tight end | Notre Dame | [n] |
| 1994 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Johnson, JoeJoe Johnson | Defensive end | Louisville | [o] |
| 1995 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Fields, MarkMark Fields | Linebacker | Washington State | |
| 1996 | &0000000000000011.00000011 | Molden, AlexAlex Molden | Defensive back | Oregon | |
| 1997 | &0000000000000010.00000010 | Naeole, ChrisChris Naeole | Guard | Colorado | [p] |
| 1998 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Turley, KyleKyle Turley | Offensive tackle | San Diego State | |
| 1999 | &0000000000000005.0000005 | Williams, RickyRicky Williams | Running back | Texas | [q] |
| 2000 | — | — No pick | — | — | [r] |
| 2001 | &0000000000000023.00000023 | McAllister, DeuceDeuce McAllister | Running back | Mississippi | |
| 2002 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Stallworth, DontéDonté Stallworth | Wide receiver | Tennessee | |
| 2002 | &0000000000000025.00000025 | Grant, CharlesCharles Grant | Defensive end | Georgia | [s] |
| 2003 | &0000000000000006.0000006 | Sullivan, JohnathanJohnathan Sullivan | Defensive tackle | Georgia | [t] |
| 2004 | &0000000000000018.00000018 | Smith, WillWill Smith | Defensive end | Ohio State | |
| 2005 | &0000000000000013.00000013 | Brown, JammalJammal Brown | Offensive tackle | Oklahoma | [u] |
| 2006 | &0000000000000002.0000002 | Bush, ReggieReggie Bush | Running back | Southern California | |
| 2007 | &0000000000000027.00000027 | Meachem, RobertRobert Meachem | Wide receiver | Tennessee | |
| 2008 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Ellis, SedrickSedrick Ellis | Defensive tackle | Southern California | [v] |
| 2009 | &0000000000000014.00000014 | Jenkins, MalcolmMalcolm Jenkins | Defensive back | Ohio State | |