| # | Wrestlers | Reign | Date | Days held | Location | Event | Notes |
| 01 1 | Petrucci A.J. Petrucci and Stahl, DougDoug Stahl (The Super Destroyers) | 01 1 | 01992-06-23 June 23, 1992 | &0000000000000283.000000283 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | Petrucci and Stahl won the titles in a tournament final. |
| 02 2 | Stetson, TonyTony Stetson and Larry Winters | 01 1 | 01993-04-02 April 2, 1993 | &0000000000000001.0000001 | Radnor, PA | Live event | |
| 03 3 | Candido, ChrisChris Candido, Johnny Hotbody, and Chris Michaels (The Suicide Blondes) | 01 1 | 01993-04-03 April 3, 1993 | &0000000000000042.00000042 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | All three wrestlers were recognized as champions, and were able to defend the titles in any combination via the Freebird rule. |
| 04 4 | Petrucci A.J. Petrucci and Stahl, DougDoug Stahl (The Super Destroyers) | 02 2 | 01993-05-15 May 15, 1993 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 05 5 | Candido, ChrisChris Candido, Johnny Hotbody, and Chris Michaels (The Suicide Blondes) | 02 2 | 01993-05-15 May 15, 1993 | &0000000000000046.00000046 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | All three wrestlers were recognized as champions, and were able to defend the titles in any combination via the Freebird rule. |
| 05.5 — | Vacated | 01 1 | 01993-07 July 1993 | &0000000000000039.00000039 | zz N/A | zz N/A | ECW vacated the title after Candido left the promotion for the Smoky Mountain Wrestling organization. |
| 06 6 | Dark Patriot, TheThe Dark Patriot and Eddie Gilbert | 01 1 | 01993-08-08 August 8, 1993 | &0000000000000054.00000054 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | The Dark Patriot and Gilbert won the titles in a tournament final. |
| 06.5 — | Vacated | 02 2 | 01993-10-01 October 1, 1993 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 | Philadelphia, PA | Bloodfest: Part 1 | ECW vacated the championships after The Dark Patriot and Eddie Gilbert left the organization. |
| 07 7 | Hotbody, JohnnyJohnny Hotbody (3) and Tony Stetson (2) | 01 1 | 01993-10-01 October 1, 1993 | &0000000000000043.00000043 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | Hotbody and Stetson were awarded the titles by ECW. |
| 08 8 | Dreamer, TommyTommy Dreamer and Johnny Gunn | 01 1 | 01993-11-13 November 13, 1993 | &0000000000000021.00000021 | Philadelphia, PA | November to Remember (1993) | |
| 09 9 | Sullivan, KevinKevin Sullivan and The Tazmaniac | 01 1 | 01993-12-04 December 4, 1993 | &0000000000000092.00000092 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 10 | Grunge, JohnnyJohnny Grunge and Rocco Rock (The Public Enemy) | 01 1 | 01994-03-06 March 6, 1994 | &0000000000000174.000000174 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 11 | Jack, CactusCactus Jack and Mikey Whipwreck | 01 1 | 01994-08-27 August 27, 1994 | &0000000000000070.00000070 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 12 | Grunge, JohnnyJohnny Grunge and Rocco Rock (The Public Enemy) | 02 2 | 01994-11-05 November 5, 1994 | &0000000000000091.00000091 | Philadelphia, PA | November to Remember (1994) | |
| 13 | Sabu Sabu and The Tazmaniac (2) | 01 1 | 01995-02-04 February 4, 1995 | &0000000000000021.00000021 | Philadelphia, PA | Double Tables | |
| 14 | Benoit, ChrisChris Benoit and Dean Malenko | 01 1 | 01995-02-25 February 25, 1995 | &0000000000000042.00000042 | Philadelphia, PA | Return of the Funker | |
| 15 | Grunge, JohnnyJohnny Grunge and Rocco Rock (The Public Enemy) | 03 3 | 01995-04-08 April 8, 1995 | &0000000000000083.00000083 | Philadelphia, PA | Three Way Dance | |
| 16 | Raven Raven and Stevie Richards | 01 1 | 01995-06-30 June 30, 1995 | &0000000000000078.00000078 | Jim Thorpe, PA | Live event | |
| 17 | Pitbull #1 Pitbull #1 and Pitbull #2 (The Pitbulls) | 01 1 | 01995-09-16 September 16, 1995 | &0000000000000021.00000021 | Philadelphia, PA | Gangsta's Paradise | |
| 18 | Raven Raven and Stevie Richards | 02 2 | 01995-10-07 October 7, 1995 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 19 | Grunge, JohnnyJohnny Grunge and Rocco Rock (The Public Enemy) | 04 4 | 01995-10-07 October 7, 1995 | &0000000000000021.00000021 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 20 | 2 Cold Scorpio 2 Cold Scorpio and The Sandman | 01 1 | 01995-10-28 October 28, 1995 | &0000000000000062.00000062 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 21 | Jack, CactusCactus Jack and Mikey Whipwreck | 02 2 | 01995-12-29 December 29, 1995 | &0000000000000036.00000036 | New York, NY | Live event | Whipwreck defeated 2 Cold Scorpio in a singles match to win the titles; Cactus Jack appointed himself as Whipreck's partner. |
| 22 | Kronus Kronus and Saturn (The Eliminators) | 01 1 | 01996-02-03 February 3, 1996 | &0000000000000182.000000182 | New York, NY | Live event | |
| 23 | Saed, MustaphaMustapha Saed and New Jack (The Gangstas) | 01 1 | 01996-08-03 August 3, 1996 | &0000000000000139.000000139 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 24 | Kronus Kronus and Saturn (The Eliminators) | 02 2 | 01996-12-20 December 20, 1996 | &0000000000000085.00000085 | Middletown, NY | Live event | |
| 25 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 01 1 | 01997-03-15 March 15, 1997 | &0000000000000029.00000029 | Philadelphia, PA | Hostile City Showdown | |
| 26 | Kronus Kronus and Saturn (The Eliminators) | 03 3 | 01997-04-13 April 13, 1997 | &0000000000000068.00000068 | Philadelphia, PA | Barely Legal | |
| 27 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 02 2 | 01997-06-20 June 20, 1997 | &0000000000000029.00000029 | Waltham, MA | Live event | The Dudley Boyz defeated Kronus in a handicap match as a result of a sidelining injury sustained by Saturn. |
| 28 | MustafaMustapha Saed and New Jack (The Gangstas) | 02 2 | 01997-07-19 July 19, 1997 | &0000000000000029.00000029 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 29 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 03 3 | 01997-08-17 August 17, 1997 | &0000000000000095.00000095 | Fort Lauderdale, FL | Hardcore Heaven (1997) | The Dudley Boyz won the championship via forfeit as a result of Mustapha Saed leaving the promotion before Hardcore Heaven took place. |
| 30 | Kronus Kronus (4) and New Jack (3) (The Gangstanators) | 01 1 | 01997-09-20 September 20, 1997 | &0000000000000028.00000028 | Philadelphia, PA | As Good as it Gets | |
| 31 | Guido Little Guido and Tracy Smothers (Full Blooded Italians) | 01 1 | 01997-10-18 October 18, 1997 | &0000000000000048.00000048 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 32 | Doug Doug Furnas and Phil LaFon | 01 1 | 01997-12-05 December 5, 1997 | &0000000000000001.0000001 | Waltham, MA | Live event | |
| 33 | Candido, ChrisChris Candido (3) and Lance Storm | 01 1 | 01997-12-06 December 6, 1997 | &0000000000000203.000000203 | Philadelphia, PA | Better than Ever | |
| 34 | Sabu Sabu (2) and Rob Van Dam | 01 1 | 01998-06-27 June 27, 1998 | &0000000000000119.000000119 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 35 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 04 4 | 01998-10-24 October 24, 1998 | &0000000000000008.0000008 | Cleveland, OH | Live event | |
| 36 | Mahoney, BallsBalls Mahoney and Masato Tanaka | 01 1 | 01998-11-01 November 1, 1998 | &0000000000000005.0000005 | New Orleans, LA | November to Remember (1998) | |
| 37 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 05 5 | 01998-11-06 November 6, 1998 | &0000000000000037.00000037 | New York, NY | Live event | |
| 38 | Sabu Sabu (3) and Rob Van Dam | 02 2 | 01998-12-13 December 13, 1998 | &0000000000000125.000000125 | Tokyo, Japan | Live event | Sabu and Van Dam won the titles during Frontier Martial-Arts Wrestling's Year End Sensation tour. |
| 39 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 06 6 | 01999-04-17 April 17, 1999 | &0000000000000092.00000092 | Buffalo, NY | Live event | D-Von Dudley defeated Van Dam in a singles match to win the championship for his team. |
| 40 | Dudley, SpikeSpike Dudley and Balls Mahoney (2) | 01 1 | 01999-07-18 July 18, 1999 | &0000000000000026.00000026 | Dayton, OH | Heat Wave (1999) | |
| 41 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 07 7 | 01999-08-13 August 13, 1999 | &0000000000000001.0000001 | Cleveland, OH | Live event | |
| 42 | Dudley, SpikeSpike Dudley and Balls Mahoney (3) | 02 2 | 01999-08-14 August 14, 1999 | &0000000000000012.00000012 | Toledo, OH | ECW on TNN | |
| 43 | Buh Buh Ray Buh Buh Ray and D-Von (Dudley Boyz) | 08 8 | 01999-08-26 August 26, 1999 | &-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1.0000000 | New York, NY | ECW on TNN | |
| 44 | Dreamer, TommyTommy Dreamer (2) and Raven (3) | 01 1 | 01999-08-26 August 26, 1999 | &0000000000000136.000000136 | New York, NY | ECW on TNN | |
| 45 | Credible, JustinJustin Credible and Lance Storm (2) (Impact Players) | 01 1 | 02000-01-09 January 9, 2000 | &0000000000000048.00000048 | Birmingham, AL | Guilty as Charged (2000) | |
| 46 | Dreamer, TommyTommy Dreamer (3) and Masato Tanaka (2) | 01 1 | 02000-02-26 February 26, 2000 | &0000000000000007.0000007 | Cincinnati, OH | ECW on TNN | |
| 47 | Awesome, MikeMike Awesome and Raven (4) | 01 1 | 02000-03-04 March 4, 2000 | &0000000000000008.0000008 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | |
| 48 | Credible, JustinJustin Credible and Lance Storm (3) (Impact Players) | 02 2 | 02000-03-12 March 12, 2000 | &0000000000000031.00000031 | Danbury, CT | Living Dangerously | |
| 48.5 — | Vacated | 03 3 | 02000-04-22 April 22, 2000 | &0000000000000125.000000125 | Philadelphia, PA | Live event | At CyberSlam, Justin Credible had won the ECW World Heavyweight Championship, while Storm had left ECW for World Championship Wrestling. As a result of the circumstances, Credible vacated the tag team championships. |
| 49 | Tajiri, YoshihiroYoshihiro Tajiri and Mikey Whipwreck (3) | 01 1 | 02000-08-25 August 25, 2000 | &0000000000000001.0000001 | New York, NY | ECW on TNN | |
| 50 | Guido, LittleLittle Guido (2) and Tony Mamaluke (Full Blooded Italians) | 01 1 | 02000-08-26 August 26, 2000 | &0000000000000099.00000099 | New York, NY | ECW on TNN | |
| 51 | Doring, DannyDanny Doring and Roadkill | 01 1 | 02000-12-03 December 3, 2000 | &0000000000000129.000000129 | New York, NY | Massacre on 34th Street | Doring and Roadkill's reign was the final one in the title's history. |