Great South Africans was a South African television series that aired on SABC3 and hosted by Noeleen Maholwana Sangqu and Denis Beckett. In September 2004, thousands of South Africans took part in an informal nationwide poll to determine the "100 Greatest South Africans" of all time. Votes were cast by telephone, SMS, and the website of the state-run South African Broadcasting Corporation television channel, SABC3, which aired a series of profiles and documentaries in the weeks leading up to the announcement of the top 100. The programme was modelled on the BBC's "Greatest Britons" series, which saw World War 2 leader Winston Churchill lead the rankings as history's Greatest Briton.
In South Africa, the list was headed by Nelson Mandela, a predictable and highly popular choice, given his global stature as a statesman and symbol of post-apartheid liberation and reconciliation. Other popular choices ranged from Professor Christiaan Barnard, the pioneering heart surgeon, to General Jan Smuts, wartime Prime Minister and co-founder of the League of Nations, to Shaka Zulu, the 19th Century warrior leader of the Zulu Nation, to Internet entrepreneur and civilian space traveller Mark Shuttleworth.
Two days after the list was announced, Nelson Mandela had already received several thousands of votes more than any other candidate.[1]
[edit] Controversy
At the time when the competition was announced, in June 2004, the SABC gave the assurance that the South African show would not ban certain political figures, as was the case in the German version which banned Nazis from the list.[2] They soon came to regret their decision when the SABC became embroiled in a national controversy over the high rankings accorded to some South Africans who were less widely regarded as "great".
For example, Hendrik Verwoerd, the "Architect of Apartheid", ranked higher on the list than Albert Luthuli, South Africa's first Nobel Peace laureate, or Chris Hani, a famous anti-apartheid activist. Also present on the list was Eugène Terre'Blanche, the head of the Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging.
Despite the original definition by the SABC that nominees need not have been born in South Africa as long as they had lived in South Africa, some[who?] people questioned the inclusion of Hendrik Verwoerd, Mahatma Gandhi, Cecil John Rhodes for the very reason that they were not born in South Africa, and J. R. R. Tolkien because he was born to an English family in Bloemfontein, South Africa, which again returned to England when he was three years old. For example, Verwoerd was born in Amsterdam in the Netherlands, his father moving the family to South Africa when he was 2, and Rhodes was born in Bishop's Stortford in the UK, moving to a farm owned by his family in the Natal colony when he was 18.
Other controversial choices included an 11th placing for Hansie Cronje, the disgraced former captain of the South African cricket squad, who admitted to taking bribes to influence the outcome of test matches.
On October 14 the SABC announced that the show was being cancelled, leaving positions 2 to 10 still formally undecided.
Letter columns in some newspapers called the show a farce and used the term "whites with cellphones" to explain the presence of Hendrik Verwoerd and Eugène Terre'Blanche high on the rankings.[3] This view was rebutted by Afrikaans singer-songwriter Steve Hofmeyr who pointed out that Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, post-apartheid convicted fraudster, scored high on the list as well.[4] According to Peter Matlare, CEO of the SABC, the show was stopped because wider participation in the voting process was necessary.[3]
When the competition was announced, the SABC defined a Great South African as someone who contributed to the country's life and development.[5] When the show was stopped, the SABC claimed that their definition of a Great South African was actually someone who contributed to South Africa's development and the promotion of humanity.[6] and the fact that quite a few people on the list did not fit this description contributed to the decision to stop the show.
[edit] The list
This is the original list of "100 Greatest South Africans", with positions 2 to 10 still to be confirmed by public vote, before the show was taken off the air:
0. Nelson Mandela, Madiba, the founder of the new South Africa (1918 - )
1. Christiaan Barnard, pioneering heart transplant surgeon (1922 - 2001)
2. F. W. de Klerk, former president and joint Nobel Peace Prize winner (1936 - )
3. Shaun Bartlett, footballer (1972 - )
4. Nkosi Johnson, child who died of AIDS (1989 - 2001)
5. Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, politician and 2nd wife of Nelson Mandela (1936 - )
6. Thabo Mbeki, second president of post-Apartheid South Africa (1942 - )
7. Gary Player, golfer (1936 - )
8. Jan Smuts, statesman (1870 - 1950)
9. Desmond Tutu, cleric and Nobel Peace Prize winner (1931 - )
10. Hansie Cronje, cricketer (1969 - 2002)
11. Charlize Theron, actress and Academy Award winner (1975 - )
12. Steve Biko, nonviolent political activist (1946 - 1977)
13. Shaka, founder of the Zulu nation (1787 - 1828)
14. Mangosuthu Buthelezi, politician and a Zulu prince (1928 - )
15. Tony Leon, politician (1956 - )
16. Brenda Fassie, singer (1964 - 2004)
17. Mark Shuttleworth, Web entrepreneur, founder of Thawte, distributor of Ubuntu Linux and second fee paying space tourist (1973 - )
18. Hendrik Frensch Verwoerd, former prime minister and primary architect of Apartheid (1901 - 1966)
19. Chris Hani, political activist who was Secretary General of the SACP when he was assassinated (1942 - 1993)
20. Bonginkosi Dlamini, also known as "Zola", poet, actor and musician
21. Patricia de Lille, politician (1951 - )
22. Johnny Clegg, also known as "The White Zulu", musician (1953 - )
23. Helen Suzman, stateswoman (1917 - 2009)
24. Eugène Terre'Blanche, white supremacist and founder of the Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging (1941 - )
25. Pieter Dirk Uys political satirist and entertainer (1945 - )
26. Paul Kruger, four times president of South African Republic (1825 - 1904)
27. Anton Rupert, businessman and environmentalist (1916 - 2006)
28. Jonty Rhodes, cricketer (1969 - )
29. Leon Schuster, filmmaker, comedian, actor and prankster (entertainer)
30. Oliver Tambo, political activist who spent 30 years in exile (1917 - 1993)
31. Steve Hofmeyr, musician and actor
32. Walter Sisulu, political activist (1912 - 2003)
33. Cyril Ramaphosa, politician and businessman
34. J. R. R. Tolkien, author (1892 - 1973)
35. Beyers Naude, cleric and anti-apartheid activist (1915 - 2004)
36. Ernie Els, golfer (1969 - )
37. Miriam Makeba, musician (1932 - 2008)
38. Patrice Motsepe, businessman
39. Trevor Manuel, civil engineer, minister of finance and politician
40. Albert Luthuli, cleric, politician and 1960 Nobel Peace Prize winner († 1967)
41. Robert Sobukwe, former political activist and founder of the PAC (1924 - 1978)
42. Tokyo Sexwale, politician and businessman
43. Danny Jordaan, politician and soccer administrator
44. Fatima Meer, scientist and political activist
45. Ahmed Kathrada, political activist
46. Joe Slovo, communist politician (1926 - 1995)
47. Natalie du Toit, disabled olympic swimmer
48. Jomo Sono, soccer coach
49. Francois Pienaar, captain of the Springboks, the winning team in the 1995 Rugby World Cup
50. John Kani, actor, entertainer and writer
51. Penny Heyns, olympic swimmer
52. Jeremy Mansfield, radio and TV personality
53. Lucas Radebe, former Bafana Bafana and Leeds United soccer captain
54. Mamphela Ramphele, political activist, academic, businesswoman and mother to the son of Steve Biko
55. Cecil Rhodes, businessman (1853 - 1902)
56. Albertina Sisulu, political activist and wife of Walter Sisulu (1919 - )
57. Aggrey Klaaste, journalist and editor who advocated Nation Building during the struggle years
58. Alan Paton, author (1903 - 1988)
59. Harry Oppenheimer, businessman (1908 - 2000)
60. Zackie Achmat, HIV positive AIDS activist and critic of government AIDS policies
61. Doctor Khumalo, soccer player
62. Jan van Riebeeck, first colonial administrator (1619 - 1677)
63. Bruce Fordyce, ultra-marathon runner
64. Enoch Sontonga, teacher, lay-preacher and composer wrote "Nkosi Sikelel' iAfrika"
65. Zola Budd, athlete (1966 - )
66. Sol Plaatje, journalist and political activist (1877 - 1932)
67. Danie Craven, rugby player and administrator (1910 - 1994)
68. Alan Boesak, cleric and fair-weather politician
69. Felicia Mabuza-Suttle, talk show host, public speaker and businesswoman
70. Yvonne Chaka Chaka, musician
71. "Baby" Jakes Matlala, boxer and junior flyweight champion
72. Kaizer Motaung, founder of Kaizer Chiefs Football Club
73. Basetsana Kumalo, former Miss South Africa, presenter and businesswoman
74. Antjie Krog, poet, novelist and playwright
75. Dullah Omar, politician
76. Mandoza, musician
77. Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, politician and former wife of Jacob Zuma
78. Raymond Ackerman, businessman
79. Nadine Gordimer, 1991 Nobel Prize-winning author (1923 - )
80. Daniel François Malan, former Prime Minister responsible for laying the groundwork for Apartheid (1874 - 1959)
81. Frederik van Zyl Slabbert, politician
82. James Barry Munnik Hertzog, former Prime Minister (1866 - 1942)
83. Hector Pieterson, a young boy whose death has become the symbol of the Soweto uprisings of June 1976
84. Sewsunker "Papwa" Sewgolum, golfer
85. William Smith, TV teacher and presenter
86. Pieter Willem Botha, former prime minister and state president (1916 - 2006)
87. Hugh Masekela, musician
88. Bulelani Ngcuka, politician
89. Jody Scheckter, Formula One world champion (1950 - )
90. George Bizos, lawyer
91. Mbongeni Ngema, playwright, actor, choreographer and director
92. PJ Powers, musician
93. Mimi Coertse, musician
94. Mrs Ples, the oldest hominid skull found at Sterkfontein cave
95. Abdullah Ibrahim, aka "Dollar Brand", musician
96. Govan Mbeki, political activist and father of Thabo Mbeki
97. Jamie Uys, Film Director (1921 - 1996)
98. Jacobus Hendrik Pierneef, artist
99. Athol Fugard, playwright (1932 - )
100. Jacob Zuma, President (2009 - )
[edit] See also
[edit] Other editions
- Other countries have produced similar shows, see also: Greatest Britons spin-offs
Germany ran their version on ZDF and called it Unsere Besten (Our Best).
The CBC ran The Greatest Canadian in 2004.
KRO (part of the Netherlands Public Broadcasting) ran the De Grootste Nederlander (The Greatest Dutchman).
The Discovery Channel (in conjunction with AOL) ran The Greatest American in May 2005 [1].
In Finland, YLE ran Suuret Suomalaiset (Great Finns).[2].
In France Le Plus Grand Français (The Greatest Frenchman) ran on France 2.
In Belgium.: De Grootste Belg and Le plus grand belge.
A Czech version called The Greatest Czech (Největší Čech) aired in June 2005.
100 Welsh Heroes was the result of an on-line poll carried out in 2003-4.
A Bulgarian version, The Great Bulgarians (Великите българи), finished in February 2007.
In Romania, the show called "Mari Români" (Great Romanians) started in May 2006; on 8 July, Televiziunea Română (TVR) presented the 100 Greatest Romanians, and on 21 October the Greatest Romanian of all the times.
In Portugal, RTP chose dictator António de Oliveira Salazar as the Greatest Portuguese.
Argentina ran their version on Telefe and called it El Gen Argentino (The Argentine Gene). Started on August 27, 2007.[7]
In Spain, Antena 3 chose the current head of state, King Juan Carlos I, as the The Most Important Spaniard in History, on 22 May, 2007.[8]
Ukraine ran their version on Inter (TV channel) and called it Великі українці (The Great Ukrainians). To broadcast 2007-2008 season, 2007.[3]
A Chilean version, called "Great Chileans" (Grandes Chilenos), aired in 2008 and the chosen winner was Salvador Allende (former socialist president).
[edit] References
[edit] External links
