| Name | Election
year |
| Adams, Charles F.Charles F. Adams | 1960 |
| Adams, Weston W.Weston W. Adams | 1972 |
| Ahearn, FrankFrank Ahearn | 1962 |
| Ahearne, BunnyBunny Ahearne | 1977 |
| Arbour, AlAl Arbour | 1996 |
| Allan, H. MontaguH. Montagu Allan | 1945 |
| Allen, KeithKeith Allen | 1992 |
| Ballard, HaroldHarold Ballard | 1977 |
| Bauer (ice hockey), DavidDavid Bauer (ice hockey) | 1989 |
| Bickell, J. P.J. P. Bickell | 1978 |
| Bowman, ScottyScotty Bowman | 1991 |
| Brown, George V.George V. Brown | 1961 |
| Brown, Walter A.Walter A. Brown | 1962 |
| Buckland, FrankFrank Buckland | 1975 |
| Butterfield, JackJack Butterfield | 1980 |
| Calder, FrankFrank Calder | 1947 |
| Campbell, AngusAngus Campbell | 1964 |
| Cattarinich, JosephJoseph Cattarinich | 1966 |
| Dandurand, LeoLeo Dandurand | 1977 |
| Dilio, FrankFrank Dilio | 1964 |
| Dudley, GeorgeGeorge Dudley | 1958 |
| Dunn (ice hockey), JamesJames Dunn (ice hockey) | 1968 |
| Eagleson*, AlanAlan Eagleson* | 1989 |
| Francis, EmileEmile Francis | 1982 |
| Gibson, JackJack Gibson | 1976 |
| Gorman, TommyTommy Gorman | 1963 |
| Griffiths, FrankFrank Griffiths | 1993 |
| Hanley, BillBill Hanley | 1986 |
| Hay, CharlesCharles Hay | 1974 |
| Hendy, JimJim Hendy | 1968 |
| Hewitt, FosterFoster Hewitt | 1965 |
| Hewitt, W. A.W. A. Hewitt | 1947 |
| Hume, FredFred Hume | 1962 |
| Imlach, PunchPunch Imlach | 1984 |
| Ivan, TommyTommy Ivan | 1974 |
| Jennings, William M.William M. Jennings | 1975 |
| Johnson, BobBob Johnson | 1992 |
| Juckes, GordonGordon Juckes | 1979 |
| Kilpatrick, JohnJohn Kilpatrick | 1960 |
| Knox III, SeymourSeymour Knox III | 1993 |
| Leader, AlAl Leader | 1969 |
| LeBel, RobertRobert LeBel | 1970 |
| Lockhart, TommyTommy Lockhart | 1965 |
| Loicq, PaulPaul Loicq | 1961 |
| Mariucci, JohnJohn Mariucci | 1985 |
| Mathers, FrankFrank Mathers | 1992 |
| McLaughlin, FredericFrederic McLaughlin | 1963 |
| Milford, JakeJake Milford | 1984 |
| Molson, HartlandHartland Molson | 1973 |
| Nelson, FrancisFrancis Nelson | 1947 |
| Norris, BruceBruce Norris | 1969 |
| D. Norris, JamesJames D. Norris | 1962 |
| Norris, James E.James E. Norris | 1958 |
| Northey, WilliamWilliam Northey | 1947 |
| O'Brien, AmbroseAmbrose O'Brien | 1962 |
| O'Neil, BrianBrian O'Neil | 1994 |
| Page, FredFred Page | 1993 |
| Patrick, FrankFrank Patrick | 1958 |
| Pickard, AllanAllan Pickard | 1958 |
| Pilous, RudyRudy Pilous | 1985 |
| Poile, BudBud Poile | 1990 |
| Pollock, SamSam Pollock | 1978 |
| Raymond, Senator Donat Senator Donat Raymond | 1958 |
| Robertson, John RossJohn Ross Robertson | 1947 |
| Robinson, Claude C.Claude C. Robinson | 1947 |
| Ross, PhilipPhilip Ross | 1976 |
| Sabetzki, GüntherGünther Sabetzki | 1995 |
| Selke, Frank J.Frank J. Selke | 1960 |
| Sinden, HarryHarry Sinden | 1983 |
| Smith, FrankFrank Smith | 1962 |
| Smythe, ConstantineConstantine Smythe | 1958 |
| Snider, EdEd Snider | 1988 |
| Stanley, 16th Earl of DerbyLord Stanley | 1945 |
| Sutherland, James T.James T. Sutherland | 1947 |
| Tarasov, AnatoliAnatoli Tarasov | 1974 |
| Torrey, BillBill Torrey | 1995 |
| Turner, LloydLloyd Turner | 1958 |
| Thayer Tutt, WilliamWilliam Thayer Tutt | 1978 |
| Voss, CarlCarl Voss | 1974 |
| Waghorne, FredFred Waghorne | 1961 |
| Wirtz, ArthurArthur Wirtz | 1971 |
| Wirtz, BillBill Wirtz | 1976 |
| Ziegler, JohnJohn Ziegler | 1987 |
* Alan Eagleson resigned in 1998 after being found guilty of fraud.
